Withings Pulse assessment

Withings Pulse review

Let’s face it: the quantified-self motion is all about strapping devices to your physique and letting them inform you issues that you simply already know. Apart from marathon-operating health club worshippers, we’re all keenly conscious that we might be taking higher care of ourselves. In fact, these fancy units do supply a way to report your knowledge in a means that makes it straightforward to trace your progress, hopefully motivating you to focus on getting your exercise graph to go up whereas your weight goes down. We’re two or three generations into the market now, and the crude pedometers of yore have been changed with models full of altimeters and accelerometers that promise to faithfully monitor every little thing from what number of stairs you’ve got climbed to how nicely you slept final night time.

Withings is a French firm that is synonymous with the entire health tracker motion; it is maybe greatest recognized for its coronary heart price screens and sensible scales that push your weight, BMI, physique fats proportion, coronary heart fee and even native CO2 ranges to the cloud. However till now, it is had a obtrusive omission in its lineup: an exercise tracker that informs you of your progress aside out of your early morning weigh-ins. Worse nonetheless, each Wahoo Health and Fitbit have encroached on Withings’ house turf with their very own weighing scales; greater than ever, Withings wants an exercise tracker to maintain individuals locked into its ecosystem.

That is the place the Pulse is available in. Just like the Fitbit One, this rubber brick packs a pedometer, altimeter and sleep tracker, however in contrast to its rivals, it consists of an optical coronary heart price sensor as properly. With each the Pulse and the Fitbit priced at $one hundred, is that this additional function sufficient to determine the French enterprise because the world heavyweight? I spent a month with this system strapped to my waistband, so comply with me as I take you thru what it is wish to have this as a continuing companion.

Gallery | sixty three Pictures
Withings Pulse evaluate




  • Small and unobtrusive
  • Wonderful battery life


  • Coronary heart fee monitoring might be a gimmick for many
  • Rubberized coating chips simply
  • Companion app presents little in the best way of motivation


Withings has crafted a superb piece of hardware which may truly beat the Fitbit One at its personal recreation. We simply want the corporate would add extra motivational instruments to its companion app.


Withings Pulse review

Whereas the corporate will get understandably defensive when individuals examine its new magnificence to the Fitbit One, every thing concerning the Pulse feels acquainted. We’re not suggesting it is a copy; simply that it is clear the 2 have been designed to occupy the identical area in our lives. Just like the Fitbit One, there isn’t any constructed-in clip that lets you connect the 1.sixty nine x zero.87 x zero.31-inch unit to your belt. As an alternative, you drive the eraser-sized gadget right into a sturdy, rubber belt clip that is robust sufficient to face up to a full day of strolling round, whereas an identical neoprene wristband permits you to take it with you to mattress.

Maintain this in your hand and you will initially really feel nervous that you simply’re about to interrupt it. Certainly, at eight grams (zero.2 ounce), it weighs lower than a pack of gum, however it’s sturdily constructed and does not buckle beneath strain (consider us; we tried). Going across the system, you will word a Withings emblem up prime in addition to a lone bodily button. On the underside edge, you will discover the micro-USB port. In the meantime, the rounded edges are naked, whereas there’s an OLED touchscreen up entrance and the optical coronary heart price monitor on the rear.

Once we opened the field, we have been relieved to seek out the corporate has correctly deserted the unique piano-black gloss that coated the pattern we examined at CES again in January. As an alternative, Withings opted for a rubberized end that hides any oily deposit out of your arms and retains your prized health gadget wanting pristine. Sadly, since you will be eradicating this gadget from its clip no less than twice a day — much more in case you use the guts fee monitor — then you definitely’ll discover the coating starting to put on away on the edges, revealing the shiny black plastic that lurks beneath. The identical factor occurs on the belt clip; after a month of day by day use, the rubber has already begun to falter.

Withings Pulse review

The corporate guarantees the gadget can final two weeks on a cost, and thus far I’ve solely wanted to prime it up twice in almost 5 weeks of testing. As soon as you’ve got exhausted the battery, recharging it takes round forty minutes. The one difficulty I encountered was that it is in any other case unimaginable to deactivate the unit, which brought on me a small drawback when taking the system on an extended-haul flight to the US. In the long run, and after some fiddling, I let the display energy down and hoped that the Pulse’s lack of an off change would not lead my flight to a untimely finish.

Relating to primary navigation, you will use the bodily key to cycle via the varied choices after which swipe on the touchscreen to get extra details about no matter knowledge the unit’s collected. One press exhibits your steps taken; two, the altitude you’ve got climbed; three, distance traveled; 4, the energy burned that day. 5 presses provides you a selection between sleep monitoring and monitoring your coronary heart price, whereas six exhibits the present time and consumer account. If you select both sleep monitoring or coronary heart price monitoring, you will have to faucet a “Crescent Moon” or a “Coronary heart” icon on the touchscreen. You then both fall asleep (voilà!), or push your finger gently onto the optical sensor. You will realize it labored once you see the inexperienced LEDs mild up. Utilizing the touchscreen, you possibly can swipe left to proper by means of these first 4 choices as much as 10 occasions, letting you see your progress for every of the final 10 days — whereas a proper-to-left swipe on the pedometer will allow you to see how lengthy the Pulse believes you’ve got been jogging that day. We discovered swiping across the system to be a clean and responsive expertise, though with 10 days’ value of knowledge, you can find your self doing loads of thumb-work.

However what of the guts price sensor itself, you ask? Nicely, we discovered that the outcomes have been fairly good, besides after we might simply completed some excessive-impression train. Then, the gadget would supply wildly divergent outcomes one after the opposite. In fact, the optical reader is much less correct than different, medically accredited strategies and it is actually meant in your resting coronary heart price. Use it within the right means, then, and it is sufficiently correct so that you can use as a information.

Naturally, utilizing the Pulse is so simple as making certain that you’ve got clipped it to your belt and that it hasn’t run out of battery. This unobtrusiveness, nevertheless, makes it very straightforward to overlook that you have it on, and there have been a number of occasions once I’d go for an extended stroll, solely to recollect afterward that I might left the Pulse hooked up to a different pair of denims. A minimum of that is the excuse I am sticking with, guv’nor.

Software program

Withings Pulse review

Withings’ ecosystem depends moderately closely upon the cloud, and you’ve got a selection of an internet site or cellular apps for accessing that info. Whereas the online-based mostly version stays in beta (it is a lengthy-overdue replace on the previous Withings web site), the Well being Mate app is now a mature, helpful companion to each the Pulse and any of the corporate’s different merchandise, just like the WS-50 Sensible Physique Analyzer. The service additionally enables you to hook in knowledge from different units and apps like BodyMedia, MyFitnessPal and RunKeeper, however alas, even should you nonetheless personal considered one of Zeo’s cellular sleep-monitoring units, that choice was nixed when the firm was shuttered.

Your very important stats are represented within the type of a “wellness” butterfly, with every of the 4 wings representing a component of your physique: weight, exercise, sleep and coronary heart price. To proceed that analogy, every part grows more and more colourful as you acquire increasingly knowledge. When you already personal one of many firm’s scales, you will discover parts of this app are already chock-full of knowledge. And in case you have the flagship WS-50 scale particularly, the app will even inform you when you’re respiration an excessive amount of CO2 whenever you’re asleep. The corporate additionally recommends that customers verify their coronary heart fee twice every week, which you’ll be able to schedule with a push alert, though they’re far too straightforward to dismiss whereas on the go. Certainly, my very own checks have been a bit “feast or famine,” which means I examined my coronary heart fee commonly once I remembered, and skipped it once I did not.

In an effort to pull the info from the Pulse to your smartphone, you want to activate the unit’s Bluetooth module with an extended-press of the button. Join the gadget to your smartphone and you will see a immediate for syncing your knowledge and updating the gadget’s firmware. Throughout our time with the Pulse, we acquired an replace that elevated the quantity of scrollable knowledge from 4 days’ value to 10, and we’re hopeful that additional tweaks will grant us much more management.

As soon as you’ve got synced your knowledge, a dialogue field gives just a little commentary in your progress. As an example, after a sedentary week, I spent the weekend strolling alongside the native shoreline and racked up about 15 kilometers. When this knowledge was uploaded to the app, nevertheless, it learn, “We exercised eighty five minutes these previous seven days. Let’s attempt to attain the really helpful one hundred fifty minutes!” adopted by a corresponding improve in that butterfly wing. It might have been egotistical of me, probably even needy, however I hoped for one thing higher than that. The Pulse itself can detect if you’re jogging and can proceed to calculate a operating interval even whenever you cease. However if you add that knowledge to the app, the one means you’ll be able to inform you’ve run is as a result of the exercise graph will probably be tinted orange as an alternative of the standard blue. Maybe it is as a result of I am a fragile flower who wants fixed encouragement, however the Pulse’s demanding-but-detached strategy to motivation did not do it for me.

The competitors

Withings’ most direct competitor is — shock, shock — the Fitbit One pedometer / sleep tracker. The 2 are priced the identical ($one hundred) and do an analogous factor in an analogous type issue. Each connect to your physique with a silicone clip and use a wristband to trace your sleeping patterns. The place the pair differs, nevertheless, is that the One presents an all the time-on Bluetooth four.zero dongle to hook up with your PC. The corporate additionally sells the Fitbit Flex, which is priced the identical because the One, however depends on a silicone wristband moderately than a waistband clip, and ditches the OLED show in favor of LED indicator lights. Nike’s FuelBand is a $149 wristband that is extra targeted in your bodily exercise and step rely (it does not monitor sleep). These stats are then transformed right into a “Gasoline” determine towards which you’ll be able to set objectives. Lastly, now that Jawbone has fastened the varied points that plagued the unique Up, the $one hundred thirty wristband gives a vibrating alarm clock and app-based mostly meals monitoring, along with the kinds of options provided on the Pulse.


Withings Pulse review

As you’ll have gathered, we usually just like the Pulse, nevertheless it has some issues that would finally hamper its success. First, until you are deeply nervous otherwise you’re beneath medical steerage, it is in all probability not wholesome to continually monitor your coronary heart price on a second-to-second foundation. And on the danger of banging on about the identical concern, we’re additionally involved about how passive the Pulse is. If you need a health tracker simply to watch your exercise, that is nice. However in the event you want motivation to remain lively, overlook it. Whereas superbly designed, the companion app is austere and detached to your wants. Do properly in every week, and it will report your step rely the identical as ever. Do badly, and it is extra of the identical. We might adore it if, throughout a sedentary week, the app raised hue and cry with a view to encourage us into stepping away from our desks. We do not assume that is asking an excessive amount of, and we’re positive that some sort-hearted soul might add that to the Well being Mate app with out an excessive amount of fuss… could not they?

 Disguise Feedback zeroFeedback