Why Southeast Asia Is Main The World’s Most Disruptive Cellular Enterprise Fashions

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Sheji HoCrunch Community Contributor

Sheji Ho is the Group CMO of aCommerce.

The way to be a part of the community

Earlier this summer time, greater than 35,000 business leaders gathered at Cellular World Congress Shanghai 2015 to debate the way forward for cellular, making it the most important-ever cellular-targeted occasion in Asia. Whereas nearly all of the convention targeted on new applied sciences corresponding to 5G and Web of Issues, I used to be joined by friends from Netflix, Line, Ola Cabs, Flipkart and Twitter to debate future enterprise fashions for the cellular Web.

Most of this dialogue steered towards China and India, however I used to be there to concentrate on Southeast Asia. This attitude (or some would say, bias) isn’t simply because my firm operates in Southeast Asia, however relatively is as a result of of our $sixteen million greenback guess that innovation and disruption in cellular might be popping out of Southeast Asia far quicker than different areas, such because the U.S., China and Japan, as anticipated.

Why? I’ll argue under that Southeast Asia is on the crossroads of two main socio-technical forces which are creating an ideal storm state of affairs: the convergence of “no-tail” and “cellular leapfrogging.”

No-Tail: Southeast Asia Jumped Straight Into Net 2.zero And Commerce Will Outlive Advert-Pushed Enterprise Fashions

Keep in mind the early millennial heyday of GeoCities homepages, and later the evolution to self-publishing/running a blog, consumer-generated content material? That superb period of Net 1.zero and, extra importantly, Net 1.5 in Western markets was what gave start to a monolithic monetization mannequin round advert networks like Google AdSense and premium advert networks via an ecosystem of “lengthy-tail” writer content material on platforms similar to Blogger.com, MovableType and WordPress.

However in Southeast Asia, the Web took off a bit later than its Western counterparts, when a tiny little website like Fb was already most Asian Web customers’ first on-line expertise — the top of the Net 2.zero wave, which hit Thailand in 2007 when Web penetration crossed the 20 % mark.

We use Thailand as a proxy for Southeast Asia as a result of the nation is probably the most developed one within the area (excluding Singapore/Malaysia) and, in contrast to Singapore/Malaysia, most VCs are likely to agree that the tendencies and classes discovered in Thailand apply throughout the remainder of the area, particularly in upcoming main markets comparable to Indonesia, Philippines and Vietnam.

In the event you examine Web penetration knowledge from the U.S. and Thailand, you’ll discover that the U.S. went via the Net 1.zero and Net 1.5 booms whereas having vital double-digit Web adoption charges of 36 % and sixty one %, respectively. In Thailand, this quantity was within the dismal single digits throughout the identical durations. It wasn’t till Net 2.zero, round 2007, that Thailand began to see Web adoption take off quickly, considerably contributing to the expansion of nationwide GDP and e-commerce.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Coming to the Web celebration late resulted in consumer-generated content material creation going straight onto closed social media methods akin to Fb, Instagram and Twitter — in impact, what entrepreneurs languished calling a “no-tail” panorama with lack of high quality lengthy-tail writer stock.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Due to the shortage of this lengthy-tail in Southeast Asia, the internet advertising business has lagged behind, forcing each established companies and startups to search for non-promoting-based mostly monetization sources. Enter e-commerce and digital items.

From Conventional Advert-Pushed Monetization Towards Hybrid And Commerce-Pushed Enterprise Fashions

One of many extra fascinating results of “no-tail” is the accelerated improvement and proliferation of distinctive and Asia-particular enterprise fashions. That is the place the Asian tradition and ecosystem meets native ingenuity and entrepreneurship. Whereas startups and Web corporations within the U.S. generally tend to go together with promoting as their default monetization technique — see Pinterest (Promoted Pins), Instagram (Carousel Advertisements) and lately Snapchat (“Vertical, Video, Views”) — Asian companies in our area have needed to look elsewhere to earn a living.

China’s Tencent is the poster youngster of this. The corporate generates greater than eighty % of their income from VAS (worth added providers, primarily digital items) and e-commerce. Lower than 10 % of their income is from promoting banner advertisements and search key phrases. One other instance is Mogujie, a feminine-targeted social buying website that raised greater than $200 million earlier than being acquired by Alibaba. Mogujie began as a Chinese language Pinterest clone, however shortly pivoted into e-commerce and social buying. In contrast to Pinterest, who makes cash off “Promoted Pins,” Mogujie struggled to monetize via promoting and needed to transfer into e-commerce to outlive.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

The identical factor is occurring in Southeast Asia because it follows an identical path as China due to comparable ecosystems. Publishers are looking for assist to monetize by means of e-commerce as a result of they wrestle being profitable from promoting advertisements via advert networks. For instance, based mostly on common Thai RPMs (income per 1,000 impressions/web page views), a well-liked native vertical writer like Cosmenet.in.th will solely make $350 per thirty days based mostly on web page view numbers from SimilarWeb. This isn’t even sufficient to cowl internet hosting charges, which is why it’s not shocking that these publishers are in search of non-conventional monetization channels resembling e-commerce.

Cellular Leapfrogging: Southeast Asia Is “Cellular-First” —  How This Will Be The Breeding Floor Of Future Enterprise Fashions

Everybody talks about how China and India are going to be the subsequent huge factor in cellular, which isn’t shocking due to how large these markets are. Nevertheless, should you normalize the numbers and take a look at cell phone and cellular Web adoption charges, Southeast Asia is definitely the extra fascinating case.

The Common Thai Consumer Has 1.four Cellular Telephones

Cell phone adoption has skyrocketed within the current years in Thailand with the newest numbers outpacing the U.S. and China when it comes to cellular cellular phone penetration. Unburdened by a desktop Web legacy and pushed by ever decrease prices of smartphone manufacturing, cellphone adoption in Thailand has accelerated to some extent the place the typical Thai individual has 1.four cell phones, or one hundred forty % adoption. Examine this to the U.S. and China, that are “solely” seeing ninety one % and seventy seven % adoption charges, respectively.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Cellular Leapfrogging: Thailand Has Surpassed The U.S. And China in Cellular Web Penetration In Much less Than One Yr After Introducing 3G

Cellular Web penetration in Thailand has jumped from a mere 1 % in 2009 to a whopping fifty six % in 2013, with the majority of the expansion coming proper after the nation’s official 3G launch in early 2013. Cellular Web adoption in Thailand beats mature markets such because the U.S. and China, which stand at forty % and 34 %, respectively.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

One other method of taking a look at that is by analyzing the share of cellular Web customers out of complete Web customers. For Thailand, this quantity is 139 %, which means that Thailand has extra cell phones related to the Web than there are Web customers. Thailand pummels the U.S. and China, whose numbers are forty seven % and seventy five %, respectively.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Corporations in Southeast Asia are noticing this development and are shortly adapting to it. For instance, Lazada now will get greater than 50 % of their visitors from cellular channels after making app improvement a precedence. They’re additionally one of many first e-commerce gamers in Southeast Asia that launched each their iOS and Android apps. MatahariMall, Lippo Group’s new e-commerce enterprise, began with their cellular web site and labored backward to create their desktop expertise. Others, resembling SaleStock, a quick-rising quick-style e-commerce website in Indonesia, are foregoing desktop utterly and solely present a cellular, albeit non-native, buying consumer interface.

The Good Storm: No-Tail Meets Cellular Leapfrogging — A Peek At The Future Of Cellular Enterprise Fashions In Southeast Asia

On the crossroads of “no-tail” and “cellular leapfrogging” we will anticipate to see a melting pot of latest and distinctive cellular enterprise fashions to Southeast Asia.

C2C Fashions: The Six Steps To Fast Social Commerce In Southeast Asia

One fascinating, and uniquely Southeast Asian, phenomenon is “shadow marketplaces.” Due to the 2 forces in play — excessive cellular penetration and content material creation targeting social media platforms — there’s been an increase of casual C2C e-commerce on social media, akin to Instagram, Fb and Line. These are usually not your small mother-and-pop shops that promote bits and items right here and there — an estimated and whopping one-third of complete Thai e-commerce GMV comes from transactions occurring on these shadow marketplaces.

That is the way it works: Retailers function their merchandise on Instagram and the transaction is accomplished by way of Line messaging, the preferred chat app in Thailand:

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models


Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

This may increasingly appear very low-tech to many people who’re used to extra “superior” and seamless e-commerce purchasing on platforms akin to Amazon and Tmall, however the societal and economical influence it has on e-commerce in Southeast Asia can’t be ignored.

B2C Fashions

On the Cellular World Congress panel, I shared the stage with Hanna Lee from Line Corp. She’s the GM for Line’s China and Hong Kong enterprise. Hanna confirmed Line’s evolution from a messaging app to a complete media answer masking digital items, music and video. In Southeast Asia, realizing the shift towards cellular commerce, the identical firm has launched a number of pilot tasks to faucet into e-commerce monetization, most notably Line Flash Sale, Line Scorching Deal and Line Groceries.

Line Groceries launched first in Thailand as a result of it’s Line’s second-largest market outdoors of Japan, with greater than 29 million customers out of a complete 600+ million customers. That is proof that huge gamers like Line are foregoing launching of their largest markets, like Japan, and leaping straight into probably the most fertile grounds for testing new and revolutionary enterprise fashions.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

B2B2C Fashions

We’ve lately seen gamers like Pinterest, Fb and Google going aggressively into e-commerce for monetization. Earlier final month, Google introduced “Purchases on Google” enabling purchase buttons on cellular. The identical day, Fb began testing digital shops with a purchase button for Fb Pages, becoming a member of the ranks of Twitter, Instagram and Pinterest who ventured into purchase buttons within the months prior. All these companies are wanting into e-commerce as a further, albeit profitable, income stream.

Nevertheless, in Southeast Asia, this will not be a luxurious function in comparison with mature markets just like the U.S. and Europe. As an alternative, enabling e-commerce by means of purchase buttons could also be a necessity, and even a survival mechanism, as a result of the market, as we argued earlier than, is commerce-pushed, not advert-pushed. Additionally, given the right match of provide and demand in Southeast Asia as we’ve seen within the shadow markets case, we anticipate adoption of purchase buttons to be a lot quicker right here.

Given the plethora of established e-commerce platforms out there, even in an rising market like Southeast Asia, one would marvel why Google and Fb enabling e-commerce is such an enormous deal. A fast take a look at precise cellular conduct in a market like Thailand helps us join the dots. Under is a picture that exhibits two cell phone house screens of a Thai highschool scholar.

Why Southeast Asia Is Leading The World’s Most Disruptive Mobile Business Models

Display one, on the left, exhibits social media and chat apps like Instagram, Fb and Line, along with a folder devoted to video games. The opposite display exhibits nothing however digital camera apps.

Three fascinating observations might be made right here:

  • There’s no Google. Regardless of Google’s current large numbers, in addition to media newly proclaiming that cellular isn’t ruining Google’s search enterprise in any respect, it will be fascinating to see these numbers damaged down by market, particularly Asia and particularly Southeast Asia. Mixing numbers and conduct throughout markets doesn’t reveal the true impression of a “cellular-first” or “cellular-solely” market like Southeast Asia. Don’t get me mistaken — Google Search is right here to remain, even on cellular. Nevertheless, its influence can be much less outstanding in our cellular age. As a MediaPost commentary factors out: “In a way, then, the rise of cellular signifies that — in some instances — search engines like google and yahoo are being leapfrogged; we’re going on to acquainted, fashionable or cellular-pleasant channels with out visiting a search engine first.”
  • There’s no YouTube. Video is shifting to Instagram, Fb and messaging apps like Line. Fb now has greater than three billion video views per day. And Line just lately launched a YouTube-like video service in — the place else however — Thailand. Line picked Thailand over its largest market (Japan) for this launch as a result of Thailand, not Japan, is a very cellular-first market.
  • There are not any commerce apps. Granted, that is an 18-yr previous highschool scholar in an rising market, however as quickly as habits are shaped, they’re very arduous to vary. Additionally, as mentioned earlier, there is probably not a necessity for commerce apps in any respect as Instagram, Line and Fb already have gotten the de facto commerce platforms in Southeast Asia. Fb, Instagram and Twitter formally going into purchase buttons will solely reinforce this, particularly on this area. This phenomenon with the subsequent era will pose a serious problem to established e-commerce retailers and platforms in Southeast Asia, given how dominant Fb, Instagram, Line and Twitter are on this area.


Pushed by two distinctive forces, “no-tail” and “cellular leapfrogging,” Southeast Asia is in a particular place to be the melting pot for brand spanking new cellular enterprise fashions. Cease wanting on the U.S., China and even Korea/Japan for inspiration for the way forward for cellular, as a result of it isn’t occurring there. Mockingly, mature and developed markets carry the heavy legacy of the desktop Web period, whereas Southeast Asia began with a clear slate, permitting the latter to be in a singular place to experiment and develop new enterprise fashions on cellular, primarily pushed by commerce.

View or obtain my Cellular World Congress Shanghai 2015 presentation – “Commerce + Cellular: Evolution of New Enterprise Fashions in Southeast Asia

Featured Picture: SAHACHAT SANEHA/Shutterstock