Samsung Galaxy S5 evaluation: a strong enchancment, however do not rush to improve

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

When Samsung unveiled the Galaxy S5 and a trio of Gear smartwatches, the corporate made an enormous to-do about the way it listens to its clients. We all know, we all know: Each firm’s purported to be doing that. However keep in mind, that is Samsung we’re speaking about. It dominates the Android market by such a large margin that it makes rivals like LG and HTC appear to be quaint startups. Put it one other approach: Samsung might launch a telephone with no enhancements, and it’d nonetheless promote hundreds of thousands.

A minimum of, that is the way it was. The smartphone market has seen a downturn of late and even mighty Samsung has been affected. Gross sales are down, and the producer should now make telephones that give individuals what they really need (shocker, we all know). So what can we anticipate from a humbled Samsung? A sturdy telephone that brings a toned-down TouchWiz UI, a greater digital camera, longer battery life, improved efficiency, a fingerprint scanner and enhanced well being monitoring. I acquired an unlocked assessment unit from GSM Nation, which was the primary outlet to start out delivery the telephone within the US with AT&T- and T-Cellular-suitable LTE. Now that I have been testing it for a number of days, let’s examine if the Galaxy S5 lives as much as all these guarantees.

Gallery | forty five Pictures
Samsung Galaxy S5 assessment

eighty three
Samsung

Galaxy S5

Execs

  • Implausible show
  • Daylight pictures are on par with different flagship telephones
  • Waterproof casing and improved design
  • Good battery life

Cons

  • Fingerprint scanner could be irritating
  • Selective focus does not all the time work as promised
  • Coronary heart fee monitor is not utterly correct
  • TouchWiz UI seems to be higher, however continues to be complicated

Abstract

The S5 is a strong improve over final yr’s mannequin, with enhancements to the hardware, software program and digital camera. Nevertheless, sure headline options just like the fingerprint scanner and coronary heart price monitor are mediocre at greatest. Likelihood is, you will be proud of the telephone, however do not fork out the additional money for an early improve.

In the event you’ve seen one Galaxy S gadget, you’ve got seen ‘em all. Every iteration of the favored smartphone collection has had a number of nips and tucks, however general it is maintained the identical look through the years. The S5 is not any exception: The one new options listed here are its squarish form and its plastic, waterproof casing — dimpled to look kind of like leather-based (it does not actually). Even then, you possibly can inform at a look that it is a Galaxy S.

If there’s one phrase we might use to explain the Galaxy S5 design, it is “inoffensive.” It isn’t precisely a visible deal with like the brand new HTC One M8, nevertheless it’s not ugly both. And that is not shocking, actually: Samsung often performs it protected with its designs. This time round, I’ve heard loads of jokes referring to the GS5 because the “Band-Assist Telephone,” a nod to these dimples on the again. Really, although, I solely see that in sure colours, particularly the gold model. Luckily, my white unit does not appear to be a Band-Help in any respect; the truth is, I choose it to the shiny covers used on the GS3 and GS4.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Certainly, there’s one thing to having a much less slippery design: I used to be capable of grip the eight.1mm-thick telephone with out feeling prefer it was going to slide by way of my fingers. Particularly, the blunt edges and principally flat again make it straightforward to wrap your fingers across the system. And that is a superb factor, because the GS5 is bigger than its predecessor in each means (5mm taller, virtually 3mm wider and zero.2mm thicker). In different phrases, for those who thought the GS4 was too giant, this yr’s model could also be an excessive amount of. It is also zero.fifty two ounce (15g) heavier, however I solely observed the distinction once I was holding one gadget in every hand. And apart from, by trendy-day requirements it is compact: In comparison with the One M8, the GS5 is shorter, thinner and lighter, and that is with a barely bigger display, too.

I discussed earlier that the GS5 is waterproof. Extra particularly, it is IP67-licensed, which suggests it may be immersed in as much as one meter of water for as much as half-hour. However earlier than you determine to take it for a swim, ensure that to shut the again utilizing the rubber gasket and seal the charging port. Curiously, the headphone jack is totally open, however someway is impervious to water.

There are just a few modifications to the button format, in comparison with final yr’s GS4. The facility button and quantity rocker are nonetheless on the best and left, respectively. There’s now a micro-USB three.zero/MHL 2.zero port on the underside, which is protected by a water-proof tab. The IR blaster, in the meantime, sits on the highest left, with the three.5mm headphone jack over on the highest proper. Moreover, the house button now features a capacitive fingerprint sensor, which I am going to talk about in additional element afterward. Round again you will discover the small speaker grille, however the largest change could be discovered farther up: Samsung put in a coronary heart price monitor subsequent to the LED flash, simply beneath the rear digital camera.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

As ever, Samsung included a detachable again cowl and a swappable battery, with a capability of two,800mAh (up from 2,600mAh). There’s additionally a microSD slot for as much as 128GB of exterior storage. Out of the field, you get both 16GB or 32GB of constructed-in storage; simply keep in mind that the working system takes up a variety of area earlier than you even get round to putting in apps or downloading films. In truth, my 16GB unit had somewhat beneath 12GB of area once I began utilizing it, so when you’re even barely involved about storing giant information, I like to recommend going with the 32GB mannequin or shopping for an enormous reminiscence card to compensate.

I will not spend loads of time on connectivity as a result of it can finally range relying on the place you reside and which service you employ (that final bit is especially true within the US). That stated, most variants function quad-band GSM/EDGE, quad-band HSPA+ forty two.2 Mbps (850/900/1900/2100) and LTE Cat four (which gives speeds of as much as one hundred fifty Mbps). The GS5 additionally helps service aggregation, which principally signifies that it may well fuse collectively LTE from totally different towers to extend your knowledge speeds. However once more, this can largely rely upon whether or not your service even helps that know-how.

Lastly, you will additionally get Bluetooth four.zero + LE, GPS/GLONASS, DLNA, USB OTG, MHL 2.zero and WiFi Direct. There’s additionally twin-band WiFi 802.11a/b/g/n/ac, however the GS5 is the primary telephone that we have seen with two-channel MIMO help. In English, it consists of an additional antenna, with which you would theoretically double your velocity — offered you’ve gotten the proper of supporting gear, in fact.

Oh, and whereas I am as regards to velocity, most variations of the GS5 include a brand new function referred to as Obtain Booster, which primarily combines the facility of LTE, WiFi and Grayskull to assist giant information obtain quicker than they might on anybody connection. The service will not work on something smaller than 30MB, and does not apply to sure protocols like FTP and UDP. However in the event you’re making an attempt to put in an app, load a YouTube video or save a film your cousin shared with you on Fb, Obtain Booster ought to do the trick. If you do not have a vast knowledge plan, nevertheless, be very cautious about how typically you employ this — when you’re not maintaining tabs in your utilization, your subsequent invoice may offer you an aneurysm.

Show

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

The S5’s 5.1-inch Full HD Tremendous AMOLED show has the identical decision as final yr’s flagship regardless of the bigger measurement display. Sure, pixel-density snobs, meaning you are subjected to 9 fewer pixels per inch (441 vs. 432). In any case, these 9 pixels have been well worth the sacrifice: The show here’s a shocking enchancment over the S4. The distinction is straightforward sufficient to see with the bare eye, particularly whenever you put the 2 units aspect by aspect.

For starters, the S5 is far brighter than the S4, not solely indoors, but in addition in direct daylight (with auto-brightness turned on, the show goes as much as round 450 nits). On the similar time, it is also able to dimming right down to as little as two nits in pitch-black rooms. This makes for a extra snug viewing expertise whenever you’re studying in a darkish bed room or (tsk, tsk) catching up on Fb throughout a film. The viewing angles have improved considerably as nicely: Even from a extreme angle, the colours are extra lifelike, and it is simpler to learn onscreen textual content. Admittedly, the HTC One M8’s S-LCD panel does a greater job with whites and darks, though the GS5 presents extra shade saturation (and it isn’t even over-the-prime saturation this time, both). As you possibly can see, I am being somewhat nitpicky right here, however I consider most customers might be proud of both show.

And should you’re not completely happy? In contrast to most non-Samsung telephones (save for Nokia), the GS5 has 5 display modes: Skilled Photograph, Cinema, Dynamic, Adapt and Commonplace. All of them use a unique shade gamut; so if one does not suit your fancy, attempt the others to see what works greatest.

Fingerprint scanner

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Till the iPhone 5s got here out, the final flagship telephone with a fingerprint scanner was the Motorola Atrix 4G — and that was three years in the past. Again then, it was clear the know-how wasn’t prepared for prime time, principally as a result of the sensors did not truly work very properly. Now, in 2014, the S5 comes with a capacitive fingerprint scanner constructed into the house button — yep, identical to on the iPhone. It stays to be seen if this results in one other courtroom battle, however regardless, you’ll be able to’t fault Samsung for selecting the house button: We contact that a part of the telephone dozens (if not tons of) occasions a day.

So, how precisely does the scanner work right here? Samsung’s setup options Synaptics’ Pure ID, which consists of a tiny sensor that sits beneath the button. (Synaptics calls it “a miniature touchpad with constructed-in capacitive sensing.”) When it is time for the telephone to study your prints, you swipe your finger over the house button a number of occasions, permitting the sensor to learn the inside reside layers of the tip of your finger. Utilizing sign power, the sensor can draw a “map” of your fingerprint and presto – you are all set. You possibly can retailer as much as three prints complete, though I might want much more.

If the sensor does not acknowledge your finger after 5 makes an attempt, the telephone will immediate you to enter an alternate password. It is an alphanumeric password, thoughts, so you will have to incorporate each numbers and letters as an alternative of a easy 4-digit PIN code. On one hand (no pun meant), Samsung possible did it this strategy to make the telephone safer, however I nonetheless consider customers ought to have the ability to select what sort of password they need.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Talking of safety, ought to we be involved about privateness? Based on Samsung and Synaptics, the reply is not any. When the sensor talks to the processor (“Hey, this print checks out simply high-quality. Go forward and allow them to in.”), all info is encrypted. What’s extra, the prints are saved regionally on the telephone, and as an alternative of storing an precise picture of your print, it solely logs a digital map. Spoofing additionally would not work; Synaptics says that any change within the bodily properties of the telephone will end in rejection.

All in all, Samsung makes extra use out of its fingerprint scanner than Apple does with Contact ID. Each the GS5 and iPhone 5s use the scanner to unlock the telephone, clearly, however that is the place the similarities finish. The one different factor Contact ID can do is approve App Retailer and iTunes downloads. Samsung, in the meantime, allows you to make on-line funds by way of PayPal, in addition to entry a personal “locker” for confidential information. I might additionally wish to see these corporations open up their sensors to 3rd-get together builders; all in due time, hopefully.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Getting right down to brass tacks, how properly does the factor truly work? It relies upon. I educated the GS5 to acknowledge each of my thumbs and my proper index finger, since these are the three digits I exploit probably the most when waking up the telephone. Over the course of a number of days, I made dozens of makes an attempt with every finger and it solely acknowledged me on the primary attempt about half the time — and that is a beneficiant estimate. Most of the time, I needed to swipe my finger two or 3 times earlier than it let me in; typing in a PIN code would’ve been extra environment friendly. Worse, there have been different occasions when the scanner would not acknowledge me in any respect, whilst I adjusted my swipe velocity, angle and finger strain. And even when it really works, there is a small delay after you swipe earlier than the telephone accepts your print.

As for one-handed use, do not even hassle. It is technically attainable, however the odds of success are so low I’ve a greater probability of seeing Narnia every time I open my closet. Usually, I maintain the telephone in my left hand and attempt to swipe the sensor with my left thumb; nevertheless, my thumb is at such an angle that the sensor merely cannot acknowledge it. Typically it’s going to work if I push the telephone up somewhat greater and attempt to place the thumb at a extra shallow angle, however even then, it takes a number of makes an attempt, and it is so off-stability that I’ve come near dropping the system a number of occasions. Apple’s sensor, however, has no drawback choosing up my fingerprint from any angle.

To be truthful, my expertise might get higher over time (though in Apple’s case, it acquired worse for some time). It is apparent there is a studying curve right here; it could possibly take follow to put your finger in simply the best place, at simply the correct velocity with simply the correct quantity of strain. Nevertheless, I do not consider most individuals shall be that affected person — after a number of irritating makes an attempt, customers may merely flip the function off (or worse, try a guaranty swap as a result of they assume it is faulty).

There is a little bit of a silver lining, at the very least: When you do not prefer it, do not need to use it or it merely does not be just right for you (or all the above), you do not have to make use of it. And in contrast to the HTC One Max, whose fingerprint scanner sits under the rear digital camera, the sensor itself is not visually distracting.

Coronary heart fee monitor

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Samsung’s been making an enormous deal about well being lately. It is provided an app referred to as S Well being for fairly a while, which helps customers monitor their train and meals consumption. Beginning with the GS4 particularly, the app’s been capable of monitor coronary heart fee and steps with the assistance of third-social gathering equipment. Now, although, each of those options are constructed instantly into the GS5, supplying you with one or two fewer health devices to hold round. That stated, the guts fee screens constructed into the brand new Gear 2 and Gear Match smartwatches combine with S Well being, so the corporate’s hoping you will purchase some health wearables in any case (as long as they’re made by Samsung, in fact).

To get began, go to the Coronary heart Fee part of S Well being. Then, as soon as prompted, put your finger over the sensor, hold nonetheless and keep quiet. Watch out the place you set your finger, although: The sensor, which makes use of a light-weight that permits it to “see” and measure your pulse, is positioned virtually instantly beneath the digital camera lens. With out your eyes immediately guiding your finger to the fitting place, it is easy to mistake the digital camera lens for the guts fee monitor. (Professional tip: You will need to hold a material useful to wipe off the lens for those who do that lots.) As with the fingerprint scanner, positioning is essential. If my finger was even barely off, the monitor could not measure my pulse and I might need to redo it. Once you’ve achieved it proper, you will know fairly shortly because it solely takes 5 seconds or so to finish the method.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Our group examined the guts fee monitor towards extra devoted health units just like the Garmin chest strap (related to a Vivofit) and the Adidas Sensible watch. After a collection of exams, we observed that the GS5’s outcomes averaged about 5 or 6 beats per minute decrease than the Garmin and Adidas. That stated, the scores did match typically, however this was the exception fairly than the rule. In different phrases, the GS5 sensor will do a very good job getting you an “within the neighborhood” studying, however you are still higher off with a standalone monitor if you’d like probably the most exact outcomes.

Software program

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

As with the hardware design, Samsung’s TouchWiz software program tends to err on the protected aspect; prior to now, Samsung solely made minor tweaks to the UI. With the GS5, nevertheless, the corporate’s Android pores and skin has acquired fairly the face-raise, leading to a design that is flatter, extra trendy-wanting. In the event you ask us, it is a step in the appropriate path — and an indication that Samsung is aware of it must clean up TouchWiz. Even so, the format is complicated. The previous TouchWiz used tabs on almost each display, however not. In the meantime, Samsung launched a brand new font, and for no matter purpose, the interface makes use of a whole lot of circles. Oddly, too, there are some inconsistencies; the settings menu makes use of giant, round icons (although you’ll be able to change to listing or tab view at any time), which makes it extra of a chore to scroll via the menu. Icons in the primary app drawer, however, hew to the previous-faculty TouchWiz look. And that is not all: There are parts of inventory Android (four.four.2 KitKat) sprinkled in as properly.

Most core apps have been redesigned to be extra visually interesting, and even the current apps menu has a recent look. However provided that Google just lately had a dialogue with Samsung about the way it can down its Android pores and skin, it is irritating that there are at the least two variations of most core apps — Samsung pushes its personal in-home software program, although Google supplies comparable apps of its personal. This implies there are two app shops, two music gamers, two browsers, two photograph gallery apps, two voice assistants and three messaging apps (4 on the AT&T model). Whereas there’s one thing to be stated about selection, that is only a tangled mess, and I’ve to marvel if the additional baggage bogs down the telephone’s efficiency. Luckily, you possibly can disguise the apps you do not plan to make use of, which at the least cuts down on the muddle.

My Journal has carried over from the Notice three, however it’s now accessible by swiping from left to proper. If Samsung is certainly fascinated about getting on Google’s good aspect, I might wish to see the corporate give us the selection between My Journal and the Google Now expertise. Curiously, it isn’t even a part of the TouchWiz launcher, however, somewhat, a separate software. As for the function itself, it is principally Flipboard with a couple of customizations — in truth, clicking on classes and hyperlinks will typically take you out of My Journal and into the precise Flipboard app.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Older Samsung options like Air browse, Air view, Sensible keep, Sensible scroll and Sensible rotation are all nonetheless right here, although they are not fairly as in-your-face as they as soon as have been. In reality, most of them are buried within the settings, so it’s a must to need them in an effort to discover them. Security Help, Blocking Mode and Straightforward Mode are additionally round.

Within the settings menu, you will discover a small, however necessary addition: a search perform. If you realize what you are on the lookout for, however do not feel like spending an hour swiping by means of 20 menus to seek out it, you’ll be able to seek for the time period and head straight there. Heck, for those who’re looking for a checkbox, the search outcomes will embrace that field within the record, so you do not even should go into the menu to toggle it.

Gallery | eighty four Photographs
TouchWiz UI on the Samsung Galaxy S5

Just like the HTC One M8, the GS5 options an excessive energy-saving mode (Samsung calls it, “Extremely energy saving mode”), which guarantees to preserve energy when you end up getting dangerously low and wish to remain afloat in case a name is available in. Whenever you flip this function on, it modifications the launcher to a easy grayscale theme, caps your show brightness and restricts most apps from working, reserving your battery for less than the duties you’d want in an emergency. Mileage will differ, however even at 10 %, you must have the ability to eke out almost a full day of battery life.

One last item value mentioning: the constructed-in “child crying detector,” which can be utilized with a Gear Watch. Put your telephone inside a meter of your baby and anytime they’ve a match, your watch will vibrate. In fact, Samsung’s fast to level out that this is not meant to exchange your babysitter, so in case you’re considering of sneaking out for a spell, do not.

Digital camera

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Samsung has a historical past of creating smartphones with good cameras, however that does not imply it may relaxation on its laurels. The competitors is getting fiercer: Nokia, Sony and even Chinese language outfits like Oppo are performing some incredible issues with imaging. And so should Samsung. With the GS5, the corporate added a 16MP rear digital camera, some intelligent new modifying tips and a brand new “ISOCELL” know-how that improves sharpness, low-mild efficiency and colour accuracy. (In case you are questioning, the entrance-dealing with digital camera continues to be capped at 2MP.)

Identical to the One M8, the GS5’s prime decision makes use of a sixteen:9 facet ratio for widescreen photographs, moderately than the normal four:three. Enjoyable reality: When you do not like going widescreen, the very best res you will get is 12MP, which is definitely a decrease decision than the GS4’s 13MP four:three digital camera. Clearly, pixel rely is not every thing, and there are different points of the imaging expertise to think about, however I nonetheless discovered this a tad disappointing.

Decision is probably going the least fascinating imaging spec on the digital camera, so let’s take a fast take a look at the opposite stuff. The GS5 has the identical f/2.2 aperture as its predecessor, in addition to a focal size of four.8mm (up from four.24mm on the GS4). The 1/2.6-inch sensor is bigger, however makes use of the identical pixel measurement of 1.12 microns. Thankfully, ISOCELL addresses the priority with having such small pixels, and we’ll cowl that shortly.

The brand new digital camera settings, in the meantime, are simpler to navigate now that they are accessible from the viewfinder and may all be present in one place. Whereas this can be complicated to some, I want it this manner over the GS4, which has a number of ranges of menus. Until you knew precisely the place to go, it was troublesome to seek out what you have been on the lookout for. Fortuitously, there’s area on the sidebar for as much as three customized shortcuts, so you possibly can drag over the settings you will be adjusting probably the most.

The digital camera modes have additionally been streamlined right here. Fairly a number of are not listed by default, however in the event you press the “obtain” choice, you will be taken into the Samsung Retailer, the place yow will discover all of them. What’s extra, Eraser, Drama and Greatest photograph modes have merged into one mode generally known as “Shot & Extra.” This can be a lot like what Nokia has carried out with its Sensible Digital camera. Whereas it makes extra sense to mix them into one mode, there’s nonetheless a lingering drawback: I do not all the time know that I want Eraser till after I’ve already taken my shot. For instance, I often do not know that a photobomber goes to step into my shot till I am truly taking the image; switching to Shot & Extra mode means I’ve to know there is a good probability that some random dude goes to attempt to turn into a part of my household portrait. Lastly, the default auto mode is now sensible sufficient to detect when it is nighttime, so it could actually modify to that exact setting mechanically. (That stated, you’ll be able to activate the photograph stabilizer impact to get much more mild, if auto does not work properly sufficient.)

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

The HTC One M8 has UFocus; now Samsung is introducing one thing referred to as Selective Focus. As with UFocus, you’ll be able to blur out the background or a goal within the foreground. The catch: You need to be inside 1.5 ft of no matter object is within the foreground. Even then, there have been many occasions once I could not get it to work. Small objects, giant objects — it did not matter. The function is temperamental, it appears, however at the least it saves the picture as a daily photograph in the event you do not succeed. Even when it does work, it isn’t good. Within the picture above, I took an image targeted on the pink sundial and once I shifted the main target to the buildings within the background, not the whole lot within the foreground truly blurred out, as you possibly can see under.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

I used to be notably impressed by the GS5’s actual-time HDR function. Usually, I’ve to probability it with HDR pictures as a result of I do not get to see the way it will end up forward of time. The GS5’s processor is highly effective sufficient, nevertheless, that it is now attainable to see what the picture will truly seem like earlier than taking it, which will increase my probability of taking an excellent photograph. This function can also be obtainable within the One M8.

Samsung additionally says the digital camera is able to specializing in targets in 300ms (zero.three second), making it simply as quick because the M8. That is made attainable by way of part detection (PDAF). In contrast to most smartphone cameras, which decide focus by means of distinction, PDAF divvies up incoming mild right into a pair of pictures after which compares the 2. If you do not have sufficient mild coming in, the digital camera will shift again to the normal distinction autofocus technique. I could not see a noticeable distinction in focus lock occasions between the GS5 and the M8 (similar goes with default shutter velocity). Both method, each have been faster than the GS4.

The GS5 additionally permits you to manually tweak the settings to your liking, however it does not supply fairly as many choices (or nearly as good a UI) as the brand new HTC One. It isn’t a lot totally different from different Galaxy telephones, both: You’ll be able to set white stability, metering technique, publicity and ISO (as much as 800). Nonetheless, HTC provides extras like shutter velocity and focus sort, together with sliders and the power to save lots of presets, so you possibly can simply change forwards and backwards between modes as an alternative of getting to vary every setting each time.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

The GS5 might not have an additional digital camera so as to add depth info, nevertheless it brings loads of nice modifying options that make you are feeling as in the event you’re having fun with Photoshop in your telephone. You’ll be able to nonetheless rotate, crop and resize; add stickers, frames and drawings; throw in portrait results; and regulate shade saturation, distinction and temperature. What’s totally different this time is the power to pick a selected a part of your photograph and tweak simply that half whereas leaving the remainder of the image untouched. In different phrases, if one a part of your picture is blown out, you’ll be able to choose that space and tweak the settings to tone it down. In case you do not actually understand how you need to regulate the shot, there’s additionally an auto-improve function which may offer you a nudge in the proper path.

The dimensions of every pixel on the GS5’s primary digital camera stays the identical as on the GS4, so does Samsung do anything to enhance low-mild efficiency? It does, within the type of its new ISOCELL know-how, which first debuted final fall. The reason of the way it all works is fairly technical and I am going to let the video above do a lot of the explaining. Briefly, ISOCELL provides tiny obstacles between particular person pixels, which will increase picture sharpness, colour accuracy and lightweight sensitivity — all features that come as disadvantages for many BSI sensors. The brand new tech additionally permits the lens to be nearer to the sensor, which makes it so the digital camera module might be smaller.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

All informed, ISOCELL improves Samsung’s imaging high quality, however the outcomes aren’t fairly nearly as good when in comparison with the One M8, Lumia 1020 and iPhone 5s. I am not saying nighttime photographs on the GS5 are horrid — they’re nonetheless completely usable typically — however the efficiency simply is not as much as par with different units which have popped up available on the market prior to now yr. Merely put, most night time photographs seem darker and noisier.

Luckily the GS5 holds up nicely in good lighting circumstances. My footage have been barely extra detailed than they have been on the GS4 and One M8. I did not need to make any changes to the settings in direct daylight, whereas the M8 tends to take blown-out photographs if I do not dial again the publicity a notch or two. Picture high quality was additionally on par with the iPhone 5s, with solely slight variations in shade saturation.

(Observe: I’ve uploaded a gallery of full-res photographs right here.)

Efficiency and battery life

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Within the yr because the GS4 got here out, we have seen two new generations of excessive-finish Snapdragon chipsets: the 800 final fall, adopted by the 801, which is what Samsung used on the GS5. As is just too typically the case, it will not be lengthy earlier than the muscle behind Samsung’s state-of-the-artwork mannequin is not the most effective out there, because the Snapdragon 805 will land in a couple of months, with the sixty four-bit octa-core Snapdragon 810 touchdown this time subsequent yr. Heck, perhaps that is what we will anticipate within the GS6!

With a quad-core 2.5GHz processor, 2GB of RAM and a 578MHz Adreno 330 GPU, the GS5 is predictably highly effective. Even so, I can not shake the sensation that one thing within the bowels of TouchWiz is stopping it from reaching its full potential. Regardless of having a quicker clock velocity than the One M8 (each telephones use a Snapdragon 801, however the M8’s model has a decrease max velocity at 2.3GHz), most transitions appear to take longer to finish and apps load barely slower than they do on the One.

Once more, it might really feel like I am making a mountain out of a molehill, however this slight lag additionally interprets into some odd happenings on the graphics aspect. My recreation checks of selection have been Asphalt eight and Lifeless Set off 2, since each want some critical horsepower to run easily. Most of my gameplay unfolded with out incident, however the titles slowed down and even froze up extra typically than they need to have, contemplating the highly effective chipset getting used.

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

The S5’s battery held up properly throughout my week of use, and it is a slight enchancment over the GS4. Nonetheless, the HTC One M8 is even higher. With heavy utilization, I tended to get involved close to the top of the day that the two,800mAh battery wasn’t going to make it. Fortunately, although, it by no means utterly gave up on me. In different phrases, the battery acquired me by means of a full day, however most of the time, it got here somewhat too near empty. In our formal rundown check, in the meantime, the battery stored going by means of almost 10 hours of video playback. That is not as spectacular because the M8, which lasted eleven and a half hours, however it’s nonetheless higher than the GS4, which gave out after 9 hours and quarter-hour. With extra average use, it is best to final right into a second day; naturally, mileage will differ relying on what you are doing together with your telephone and the way robust your sign is.

Audio on the GS5’s audio system is not fairly as loud or clear as BoomSound on the One M8. Worse, the sound rattled the again of the telephone anytime I cranked up the quantity. In reality, the louder the music acquired, the extra muffled and blown-out the sound turned. Plugging in a pair of headphones helped me to sidestep the issue, no less than. Likewise, name high quality on each my unlocked handset and my AT&T model sounded clear with no complaints on both finish of the road. Bluetooth connectivity labored flawlessly, even with a number of units related on the similar time, and NFC carried out in addition to I might hoped. GPS navigation did not have any noticeable points, both.

Wrap-up

Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

Likelihood is, you will be proud of the Galaxy S5 for those who select to purchase it. It is a strong improve to the Galaxy S4, with affordable enhancements to the design, software program and digital camera. I can not say that is your most visually interesting choice, particularly in comparison with the all-metallic HTC One M8, however the dimpled again and waterproof casing at the least add extra sturdiness than we have loved on earlier Galaxy S units.

The fingerprint scanner and the guts fee monitor, however, want some work. Every delivers inconsistent outcomes and may be fairly irritating to make use of. The excellent news is that you do not have to make use of them when you have the identical expertise that I did; the dangerous information is: When you do not reap the benefits of these options, you will have fewer causes to purchase the telephone within the first place. What’s extra, Samsung put lots of power into integrating these options into each the GS5’s hardware and software program, which makes me marvel what the corporate might have included as an alternative if it left these out. In the event you’re on the lookout for an excellent Android telephone, the GS5 will not allow you to down. I might be glad utilizing this as my day by day driver. That stated, I would not waste an early improve on it, both.

Edgar Alvarez produced the video evaluation.

 Disguise Feedback zeroFeedback

<a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/s5/”> Samsung Galaxy S5 </a>

  • Key specs
  • <a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/s5/” title=”Samsung Galaxy S5 evaluations” goal=”_blank”> Evaluations 22 </a>
  • Costs
  • Discussions
  • Sort Smartphone
  • Working system Android (KitKat [4.4])
  • Display measurement 5.1 inches
  • Inner reminiscence sixteen GB
  • Carriers (US) AT&T
  • Dimensions 5.fifty nine x 2.eighty five x zero.32 in
  • Weight 5.eleven oz
  • Launched 2014-04-eleven

see all specs →

eight.2common consumer score
  • Reception and name high quality eight.eight
  • Show eight.9
  • Battery life eight.eight
  • Digital camera eight.9
  • Ease of use 7.6
  • Design and type issue 6.eight
  • Portability (measurement / weight) eight.2
  • Media help eight.four
  • Sturdiness eight.2
  • Ecosystem (apps, equipment, and so on.) 7.7

Get higher critiques from individuals who even have this product!

write a evaluationsee all critiques →

Displaying costs for mannequin:

AT&T 16GB-BlackAT&T 16GB-WhiteDash 16GB-BlackDash 16GB-WhiteVerizon 16GB-White

  • Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade + tax & delivery Purchase now
  • Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade on contract Purchase now
  • Featured Tales
    Examine Your Devices

    Samsung Galaxy S5 review: a solid improvement, but don't rush to upgrade

    Immediately examine merchandise aspect by aspect and see which one is greatest for you!

    Attempt it now →