Samsung Galaxy Notice Edge evaluation: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

Simply since you can do one thing, do you have to? Samsung thinks so. Its second experimentally screened telephone faucets into its hardware R&D and manufacturing clout to supply one thing not many different corporations could make, not to mention deliver to the general public outdoors of a fuzzy proof of idea. And so, following the Galaxy Spherical, this is the Galaxy Edge. When you take the essential form and idea, it is the spitting picture of the curved-display Youm prototype spied at CES rather less than two years in the past. Now, although, it is a for-actual smartphone you should purchase. I have been testing it out in Japan, the place it launched as an alternative of the Observe four, though each the Word four and the Word Edge will ultimately be out there within the US. Fortuitously, regardless of the weird, (addictively stroke-in a position) curved display, it nonetheless packs all the good issues that made the Word four such a robust selection. However bragging rights apart, is there sufficient of an argument for a curved display? Do you have to simply get the Notice four anyway?

Gallery | 23 Photographs
Samsung Galaxy Observe Edge evaluate

eighty five
Samsung

Galaxy Notice Edge

Execs

  • Lovely, excessive-decision curved show
  • Lengthy battery life   
  • Good digital camera
  • Just about a Galaxy Word four

Cons

  • Not sufficient makes use of for the curved edge
  • Not splendid for left-handed customers
  • Just about a Galaxy Notice four

Abstract

The Galaxy Word Edge is an experiment, but it is one which’s capable of stand on its strengths, regardless of any reservations you may need about that curved show. Briefly, you get all the advantages of the Galaxy Observe four, however with a hardware twist to set it aside. Sadly, there’s that worth.

Hardware

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

The Galaxy Notice Edge grabs your consideration. Its curves are subjective and divisive; my pals and colleagues have provided up reactions starting from outright bemusement to adoration. The display appears nice, with the punchy distinction and sharpness that is been a Samsung flagship mainstay for years. We’ll get again to that edge, however it’s the headline a part of a 5.6-inch Quad-HD+ show. (“Plus” right here, compared to the Word four, means a further one hundred sixty rows of pixels.) This implies just a little chunk of additional display makes the telephone simply lower than 4mm wider, and round 2mm shorter, than the Observe four.

The display is marginally smaller than the Notice four, regardless of the cranked-up pixel rely. Just like the Notice four, textual content pops a bit of extra, and footage you’re taking with the 16MP digital camera are clearly higher replicated on the Word Edge’s display. Colour purists: Yep, the shades are nonetheless a bit of overdone, however you possibly can select from a number of customized shade palettes should you’re not a fan of excessive-distinction menus and photographs.

Regardless, you get the sensation that that is the bleeding fringe of Samsung’s telephone-making expertise, proper right here in your hand, and that is due to the curve. Samsung’s defined, formally, that it put the curve to the correct to duplicate how we learn books. Lefties aren’t going to be too comfortable, however the one-sided design is what provides the telephone a kick. (For the ten % of our readers which are left-handed, you’ll be able to flip the telephone round and the display will comply with, however the bodily residence button, ports and quantity controls (not to mention the mic for voice calls), will all be in nonsensical locations. We drafted in lefties to match it with the Word four and the latter was deemed rather more snug. (What is the use in a curved display if it is within the improper place?)

The corporate was capable of curve the show utilizing the identical know-how it featured on the Galaxy Spherical, however there’s extra emphasis right here on giving function to the individuality of the Edge. Samsung’s crafted what’s greatest described as a particular type of edge “widget,” however I am going to clarify what kind of worth it provides within the software program part. There’s some objective to it — however maybe not fairly sufficient.

Top-of-the-line issues concerning the Galaxy Notice Edge is how a lot it resembles the Word four. The truth is, barring that giveaway proper edge, from almost all angles it seems to be just like the Notice four, and that is a superb factor. It has almost all the identical design touches and materials finishes because the Observe four. As my colleague Brad talked about in his evaluate, the leather-based-like backing on Samsung’s telephones this yr is far improved: It seems and feels a lot classier, and the pretend stitches are gone too.

There are additionally machined-aluminum buttons to match the edges, an IR distant and headphone socket up prime, and a USB charger, a downgrade from the Word three, on the base. This implies slower transfers, however I can cope for the aesthetics. In time-honored Samsung type, there’s additionally a bodily house button with capacitive multitasking and again buttons balancing out the decrease bezel. Lastly, there is a constructed-in coronary heart price monitor nestled alongside the flash, whereas a single speaker grille sits within the decrease-left nook, able to be obscured by your hand whenever you maintain it. Whoops.

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

There’s been no corners minimize as regards to specs — fantastically, it goes toe to toe with the Notice four. It is the identical excessive-decision (2,560 &occasions; 1,600) display — we’re sure a mere 1080p “Plus” curved show would have been cheaper to make — in addition to a 2.7GHz processor, 3GB of RAM and 32GB of storage (and a 64GB choice), with a microSD slot for enlargement. On paper, the one place that is been restricted is the battery: a smaller three,000mAh pack powers this particular version Notice, in comparison with three,220mAh in Word quantity 4.

The stylus is one other product of Samsung’s collaboration with Montblanc: A number of sensitivity ranges and a pleasant grippy floor are the highlights. I might level you to our Observe four evaluation for a better look, however suffice to say that the stylus has become an actual promoting level for the Word collection, with one caveat: There is a steep studying curve to utilizing it. After utilizing the Galaxy Word 2 for a while, the additional options and modifications meant I got here typically unstuck initially. My private favourite, which I used a shocking variety of occasions, was Picture Clip, which lets you copy and paste elements of your display — maps, elements of a picture — and reserve it for reference or use later. Combining my scraps with a messaging app was simplicity. The brand new pen even permits you to batch choose elements of textual content and even information and footage — sure, an actual productiveness device!

One-handed use

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

Disclaimer: Your hand is totally different from mine, however it appears solely truthful to do the identical comparability we did for the Notice four. The Observe Edge is wider than the Word four, and though I’ve solely spent a quick time with the latter, the curved, tapered aspect of the Observe Edge appeared to suit quite snugly into the nook of my palm. I by no means discovered it uncomfortable, however please do not forget it stays an enormous telephone. Each include software program tips like shrinkable keyboards in addition to a brand new, tiny floating menu that may be caught to the outer fringe of the display. This duplicates the capacitive button row, which might be an answer of types for lefties. I may even make this secondary menu clear, permitting me to take care of all that display area. The power to shrink the likes of Chrome and Google Maps to a popup window and layer it on prime of different apps can also be helpful; I might like to see one thing comparable on the iPhone 6 Plus.

And the way does Apple’s largest telephone examine to the Notice Edge? Properly, each stay unwieldy to grip, and the Notice Edge is wider. Nevertheless, the edged display nuzzles into my hand higher and people software program tweaks talked about above give it the benefit. Nevertheless, identical to the stylus, there’s some time earlier than you get the knack of all of the little provisions Samsung’s made to ease customers into this display measurement.

Software program

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

For those who’re trying to study extra concerning the stylus’ makes use of, I might advise a fast learn of Brad’s Galaxy Notice four evaluation, as a result of the setup is equivalent right here. Sure, there are TouchWiz bits operating on Android four.four KitKat, however Samsung continues to clear away pointless bloat and choices. It is nonetheless a piece in progress, although, and I really feel the settings menus are notably obtuse in comparison with different Android telephones — and particularly iOS. It takes some getting used to.

However let’s concentrate on what’s totally different right here: that edge. There are two show modes you’ll be able to flit between: a slender, unassuming bar that may show a custom-made message and a extra substantial column that makes an attempt to supply additional performance, notifications or context-dependent menus for sure apps, just like the digital camera. When it is expanded, the UI is a primary row of icons, which you’ll be able to navigate with slightly swipe. This will likely look slightly uncommon, however swishing by way of the varied mini-screens (you possibly can configure what it exhibits, and even set up third-get together “edges”), is immensely satisfying.

When you can cycle by means of as much as seven edges (why the restrict?), every can be toggled off, so you would strip it down to easily a notification and app shortcut bar. Or you possibly can maintain seven various things there: climate, shares, weird reminiscence-matching recreation, your pedometer stats or a Japan-solely navigation bar that’ll supply visitors alerts and your nearest practice station. Predictably, there is a option to go on these edge apps — did Samsung not study from these early wearables? The sting might be a lot extra helpful with Spotify controls or a Gmail notification bar that gives extra than simply a lot of unread emails.

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

The sting of the display additionally comes into its personal when Samsung went to the trouble so as to add devoted menus. For the digital camera, this implies your viewfinder is not obscured, which is good. Equally, when enjoying video, you get the fullscreen playback, and tapping the display brings up controls alongside the curved edge. Notifications may even seem right here, which is a pleasant contact. Nevertheless, app-dependent edge features cease there, and the digital camera and video participant each appear to be probably the most helpful situations for it.

I ended up utilizing the sting display in a different way. I felt like my apps belong higher on the aspect, and customised the favorites edge to incorporate all my common apps like Chrome and Maps. Relatively than squeeze as many of those very important apps onto a house display (or two), I can home them on that swipeable aspect. The display can then showcase wallpaper, or suitably fairly widgets. Apps are then not a button press, however a graceful away. Samsung (and Apple) won’t prefer it, however it jogs my memory very a lot of my Mac setup.

You can even flip the sting right into a centimetered ruler. Unsure how a lot you are going to use that perform — I did not use it as soon as. One thing I did like was the night time clock setting, which, when it hits a sure prescribed time, will mild up the sting with a easy clock readout.

These could be one of the best elements, however the marvel stays the technical accomplishment of the curved display. The purposes for it do not fairly quantity to sufficient — at the least proper now. What does the sting lack? What do I would like? I am not even positive, however when textual content scrolls down the sting and also you’re dealing with the suitable aspect, the sting, of the telephone, it is upside-down. If Samsung have been to reverse it, then it would be upside-down whenever you’re utilizing the factor. It is notably irritating for the Twitter widget, which scrolls by means of highlights.

Digital camera

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

Once more, Samsung did not reduce any corners when it got here to the telephone’s imaging prowess. The Observe Edge packs a sixteen-megapixel digital camera, with Samsung’s “sensible OIS” meant to eke the sunshine (and element) in harder lighting. The entrance-dealing with digital camera can also be a prime-finish sensor in comparison with the competitors, three.7 megapixels with an f/1.9 lens. There’s additionally a (weird-sounding) selfie mode that stitches a trio of images collectively for widescreen, “greatest buddies!” seize — when you’ve got greater than two BFFs.

Gallery | 17 Photographs
Samsung Galaxy Notice Edge photograph samples

Whereas I am not an enormous selfie taker, you will need to ask our Senior Selfie Editor, however I do take an entire lot of pictures with my smartphone, so I used to be to see how Samsung’s latest smartphone digital camera dealt with (yup, it is within the Notice four, too). Fortuitously, I hung out with the Observe Edge in Tokyo and New York: two locations the place pattern photographs might be finished just about all over the place.

All informed, it is a superb digital camera. The picture stabilizing works properly on all of the neon lights that pepper Tokyo, whereas even individuals have been neatly captured. There’s some noise, however it compares favorably towards older Galaxy telephones. Daylight meant easy captures and a few very nice photographs, if I say so myself. Focus was swift, and auto white stability appeared to gauge scenes completely. In case you have a proclivity for HDR, relaxation assured the Edge does a superb job there.

Efficiency and battery life Samsung Galaxy Notice Edge Samsung Galaxy Notice four Samsung Galaxy S5 iPhone 6 Plus Quadrant 2.zero 23,861 24,425 24,714 N/A Vellamo three.zero 1,882 1,808 1,656 N/A 3DMark IS Limitless 19,912 20,692 17,954 17,902 SunSpider 1.zero (ms) 788 793 820 388 GFXBench three.zero Manhattan Offscreen (fps) 18.four 18.eight eleven.5 18.2 CF-Bench forty,143 forty three,234 33,351 N/A SunSpider: Decrease scores are higher.

It bears repeating: Samsung’s handled the Galaxy Edge purchaser to a number of the greatest elements beneath that curved show: 3GB of RAM to make sure multitask windowing runs easily, and a quad-core Snapdragon 805 processor to again it up. Just like the Observe four, lag and slowdown merely did not occur. Nevertheless, there have been the occasional hiccups the place the sting widget would refuse to cycle to the subsequent web page. The one repair I discovered was to reset the telephone. It is a disgrace, as it is a minor problem that stops the telephone getting full efficiency marks.

The Edge goes toe to toe with the Notice four, as a result of properly, it is just about the identical telephone. However how concerning the smaller battery, one of many solely hardware variations? With somewhat extra display decision and fewer capability on the cell, we feared the more severe. Nicely, in our battery of… battery exams, it lies someplace between the Notice and Galaxy S collection. It isn’t fairly nearly as good as the previous, however higher than the latter: A really heavy day of use (a lot of maps, a lot of photographs) will tucker out the telephone earlier than bedtime. That stated, in our video-loop battery check at half brightness, the Word Edge’s three,000mAh cell ran out after simply over 10 hours. With extra average use, the telephone would arrive again at my home with round 20 % left, sufficient to inform me that I wanted to cost. The fingerprint sensor to unlock the telephone is extra delicate and correct than previous Galaxy units, though the guts fee sensor on the again of my Notice Edge did not appear to select up my pulse in any respect. I wasn’t lifeless, and a second Word Edge we picked up for testing did supply up readings swiftly contained in the telephone’s S Well being app.

The competitors

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

With regards to massive smartphones, we have by no means had fairly as many robust choices. What was as soon as the area of solely Samsung and LG now has competitors from Apple and even smaller upstarts like OnePlus. Samsung has launched the Word Edge mere months after its personal Observe four, and the telephones are similar in so some ways. The key distinction is not that the battery’s smaller on the Edge, however the worth: off-contract the Word four is available in at round $800. The Word Edge, in the meantime is priced at $950 — simply shy of 200 bucks extra. On-contract pricing on AT&T involves round $four hundred, whereas the Observe four and the iPhone 6 Plus ring in at $300. Apple’s iPhone 6 Plus, missing a stylus, however coming with the slicker iOS eight, begins at $750 off-contract for a 16GB mannequin. In contrast to each of this yr’s Galaxy Notes, nevertheless, you’ll be able to’t improve the storage — one thing value taking into consideration. Then there’s the OnePlus One: a decrease-decision (however nonetheless beautiful) 5.5-inch 1080p show, no stylus, no add-on storage, however you would purchase three and have spare change for instances in comparison with the Galaxy Observe Edge. It boils right down to how a lot you need a stylus, and the way a lot you are prepared to pay for a telephone that is not like anything.

Wrap-up

Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick?

Is the Word Edge a gimmick? It is onerous to say, however I do not assume the curved show is a nasty factor. One of the best half is that even with out the sting, you’ve got nonetheless received, for all intents and functions, a Galaxy Notice four, with a stylus, energy, lengthy battery life and a succesful digital camera. The extra I used the Observe Edge, the much less the sting half appeared to matter: I might use the shortcuts to apps from the sting, however progressively disabled a lot of the widgets. Pervasive makes use of for the curve aren’t fairly there. What did stay was how gosh-darn eye-catching the show was, augmented by that curved AMOLED glow. And if foldable smartphones and tablets are going to occur, if units with extra helpful, progressive shows are to seem, telephones just like the Observe Edge are the iterations that have to occur. In the event you favored any of the earlier Galaxy Notes, or have been no less than intrigued by them, then the Galaxy Word Edge deserves the identical quantity of consideration — even when, at $980 off-contract, you are actually paying for that progress.

 Cover Feedback zeroFeedback

<a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/observe/three/”> Samsung Galaxy Notice three </a>

  • Key specs
  • <a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/notice/three/” title=”Samsung Galaxy Observe three critiques” goal=”_blank”> Evaluations sixty three </a>
  • Costs
  • Discussions
  • Sort Smartphone
  • Working system Android (Jelly Bean [4.3])
  • Display measurement 5.7 inches
  • Inner reminiscence 32 GB
  • Carriers (US) AT&T
  • Dimensions 6 x three.1 x zero.33 in
  • Weight 5.9 oz
  • Launched 2013-10-01

see all specs →

9.1common consumer score
  • Reception and name high quality 9
  • Show 9.9
  • Battery life eight.9
  • Digital camera eight.eight
  • Ease of use eight.eight
  • Design and type issue eight.eight
  • Portability (measurement / weight) eight.6
  • Media help 9.7
  • Sturdiness eight.5
  • Ecosystem (apps, equipment, and so forth.) eight.9

Get higher critiques from individuals who even have this product!

write a assessmentsee all evaluations →

Displaying costs for mannequin:

AT&T-WhiteAT&T-BlackDash-BlackDash-WhiteVerizon-BlackVerizon-White

  • Samsung Galaxy Note Edge review: Innovation, experiment or gimmick? on contract Purchase now