Samsung and HTC telephones go head-to-head in an ‘uncheatable’ benchmark check

Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test

Keep in mind the allegation that Samsung cheats at benchmarks? Regardless of the producer’s semi-denials, there’s rising proof to recommend that not solely Samsung, but in addition a variety of different Android telephone makers interact in some degree of chicanery. Often, it includes programming a tool to briefly ramp up its efficiency if it detects the launch of a benchmark check, whatever the penalties for battery life or processor temperature. This leads to a better rating on the bogus check, however one that’s unrepresentative of what the system might truly obtain if it needed to tempo itself for a actual-world process that lasted for an extended time period — corresponding to a 20-minute bout of gaming.

Up to now, so dangerous. Nevertheless, a startup referred to as GameBench reckons there’s one other method. Its founders, who beforehand labored at chip corporations like ARM and MediaTek, declare to have developed an “uncheatable” efficiency check that can be utilized to corroborate (or refute) the scores from conventional benchmarking apps, and which may help to rank Android telephones and units based on their true gaming capabilities. Though GameBench’s app continues to be in beta and certain will not be launched till the primary quarter of subsequent yr, it has already collected scores for 2 units, the HTC One and the Samsung Galaxy S four. Sarcastically, as you are about to see, Samsung may very well have much less to worry from this cheat-free check than a few of its rivals.

Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test

As an alternative of throwing an artificial, predictable and brief-lived activity at a telephone, like sure different benchmarks do, GameBench’s app runs within the background whereas a real recreation title is being performed. It takes quite a few measurements of the system, together with the median body fee and the speed of battery drain. If we take a look at these two measurements for the GS4 and HTC One, throughout 4 totally different video games, it is clear the Samsung telephone delivers a lot smoother gameplay, albeit on the expense of barely greater battery drain. GameBench’s builders level out that that is one thing you’d by no means have been capable of inform from a well-liked Android benchmark like GFXBench, whose “T-Rex” check scores these telephones as having completely similar graphical efficiency.

Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test

Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test

GameBench makes use of an algorithm to weigh up all its totally different measurements from a pattern of the preferred video games within the Google Play Retailer, decreasing all the info to a single, remaining rating. This rating rewards the Galaxy S four for getting nearer to 30 frames per second in Actual Racing three, for instance, however takes one thing away for the comparatively quick battery drain throughout this recreation. In the meantime, despite the fact that the HTC has a lot slower battery drain on Minion Rush, it will not get a lot of a reward as a result of it was solely capable of run the sport at 19fps — a body price thought-about too janky to be a lot enjoyable. When all that is added up, the Galaxy S four is left with a transparent lead. And, once more, that is shocking given GFXBench’s equal scores, or what the hardware specs for these telephones would have us consider — in any case, they each run off the identical Snapdragon 600 processor.

Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test

The upshot, in accordance with this proof, is that anyone who’s trying to play graphically intensive video games on their smartphone ought to keep away from relying solely on one or two artificial Android benchmarks — simply as PC players depend on a number of body fee charts for actual video games once they’re purchasing for a brand new graphics card. And, if there’s any dishonest happening, then it is HTC — not Samsung — that stands out for snatching GFXBench scores that it does not rightly deserve.

“GameBench’s technique of amassing knowledge strikes us as extra complete than normal graphics benchmarks”

At Engadget, we might all the time take a look at a variety of exams when reviewing a telephone, somewhat than any single app, and certainly the benchmarks we utilized in our evaluations of those two telephones already put the GS4 properly forward of the One when it comes to general efficiency. However, GameBench’s technique of amassing knowledge strikes us extra complete than some normal benchmarks, and as one thing that would turn out to be an fascinating useful resource for Android players, so we’ll be trying to glean extra outcomes from it within the close to future — together with the way it compares main chipsets just like the Snapdragon 600 and 800 and Samsung’s Exynos Octa. Judging from another stats we briefly glimpsed throughout a go to GameBench’s HQ, we might be in for a number of extra surprises.

 Cover Feedback zeroFeedback

<a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/s/four/”> Samsung Galaxy S four </a>

  • Key specs
  • <a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/samsung/galaxy/s/four/” title=”Samsung Galaxy S four evaluations” goal=”_blank”> Evaluations ninety eight </a>
  • Costs
  • Discussions
  • Sort Smartphone
  • Working system Android (Jelly Bean [4.2])
  • Display measurement 5 inches
  • Inner reminiscence sixteen GB
  • Carriers (US) AT&T
  • Dimensions 5.38 x 2.seventy five x zero.31 in
  • Weight four.fifty nine oz
  • Launched 2013-04-27

see all specs →

eight.5common consumer score
  • Reception and name high quality eight.9
  • Show 9.5
  • Battery life 7.eight
  • Digital camera eight.6
  • Ease of use eight.four
  • Design and type issue eight.6
  • Portability (measurement / weight) 9.1
  • Media help 9
  • Sturdiness 7.eight
  • Ecosystem (apps, equipment, and so forth.) eight.eight

Get higher critiques from individuals who even have this product!

write a assessmentsee all critiques →

Displaying costs for mannequin:

AT&T-BlackDash-BlackDash-White

  • Samsung and HTC phones go head-to-head in an 'uncheatable' benchmark test + tax & delivery Purchase now