Gear S2 evaluation: Samsung's greatest smartwatch continues to be a piece in progress

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

Samsung is studying. After a string of smartwatches that did not turned bestsellers, the Korean firm determined to reshape its imaginative and prescient of wearables — and I imply actually reshape. Its newest, the Gear S2, is a Tizen-powered watch that lastly has a spherical display and lastly works with telephones that Samsung did not make. Extra importantly, the corporate dreamed up a round interface with a neat rotating bezel that does not rely as closely on faucets and swipes as its rivals. What we finally get within the Gear S2 is not an ideal smartwatch — removed from it — however a set of excellent concepts that may’t fairly make up for the shortcomings of its software program platform.

seventy seven

Gear S2


  • Spinning bezel interface is sensible
  • Strong battery life 
  • Glossy, minimal seems to be
  • Works with non-Samsung telephones


  • Restricted app choice
  • S Voice is hit-or-miss
  • Vibrations really feel somewhat weak


Samsung’s newest smartwatch packs a considerate, elegant interface made attainable by a rotating bezel, with respectable battery life and a fantastic display rounding out the function record. Alas, the type of finish-to-finish management over hardware and software program that made the Gear S2 potential additionally means customers need to be okay with the choice Tizen OS and its small ecosystem of apps.


Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

Samsung has a number of S2 fashions within the offing, however I have been utilizing the usual chrome steel model with a white elastomer band ($300). It is a shockingly understated affair in comparison with Samsung’s earlier work and certainly, a fast tour does not reveal an entire lot. There are Residence and Again buttons (that sometimes do the identical issues) at 2 and four o’clock on the dial, together with a teensy microphone gap etched in between. The S2 has the muted allure of a Swatch, and its modern strains and durable development make it one of many nicer smartwatches I’ve fiddled with in an extended whereas. (Fashion professionals may choose the $350 Gear S2 Basic, which is barely smaller and comes with a leather-based band).

On the again you will discover a coronary heart fee sensor and quick access to the 2 fast-launch latches for the watchband. Swapping these bits is a bit trickier than I anticipated — most smartwatches I’ve used with swappable bands snap into the edges with pretty commonplace spring bars, however the bands for the Gear S2 slide and lock into grooves constructed into the watch’s lugs. Complete acclimation time: about three minutes. The mechanism retains the S2’s curvy strains wanting good, nevertheless it’s harder to seek out low cost third-get together straps in consequence; you will want to show to Samsung’s personal line of watchbands as an alternative. And naturally, you will not discover any of this stuff earlier than the 1.2-inch, 360 x 360 display — it is an attractive, pixel-dense show with vibrant, poppy colours and plenty of distinction, which helps whenever you enterprise outdoors. There are 15 pre-loaded watch faces, together with seven you’ll be able to customise with problems.

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

The S2’s innards will sound acquainted to smartwatch followers — a twin-core 1GHz processor with 512MB of RAM run the present (with shocking oomph, however extra on that later). Higher connectivity in watches is attending to be de rigueur, too, so the S2 packs a WiFi radio to maintain the notifications flowing in even when the watch is not related to a telephone by way of Bluetooth. Whereas we’re speaking about Bluetooth, you’ll be able to sync music over to the watch and take heed to these tracks on the transfer with a pair of wi-fi headphones. Simply be considered about it; customers can solely entry about 2.5GB of the 4GB of onboard storage. There’s even an NFC radio in there, although you’ll be able to’t use it for a lot simply but. Nevertheless, Samsung says the watch will ultimately help Samsung Pay transactions because of a software program replace coming in a month or two.

Taking it for a spin

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

I am advised I generally tend to go overboard with the adjectives, so I am going to hold it brief: The Gear S2’s bezel is one of the best smartwatch interplay technique I’ve ever used. Full cease. You will nonetheless be tapping on that round display fairly regularly, however simply spinning the bezel round takes you additional than you’d assume. Say you are gazing your watch face. Spin the bezel a couple of clicks to the left and you have got a operating tally of notifications from distinction sources; in my case, I often had totally different notification screens for Outlook emails, calendar entries and Hangouts messages.

Crank the bezel to the proper and you will be sifting by means of widgets for put in apps — by default, you possibly can shortly look at your app shortcuts, steps taken, calendar occasions, climate, music controls, coronary heart price and day by day well being rundown. In the meantime, every flip of the bezel is punctuated by a couple of extremely satisfying clicks; they’re so satisfying, in reality, that spinning the bezel shortly turned my go-to tic when simply standing round. Extra importantly, the movement simply is sensible. There’s one thing pure about spinning a dial to sift by means of messages or cycle by way of app menus, making Android Put on’s countless menus and even the Apple Watch’s principally nice Drive Contact really feel a bit cumbersome by comparability. I would not thoughts if everybody used this interface (though Samsung’s legal professionals may really feel in any other case).

Software program

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

So, sure, the hardware is surprisingly nice — what else does this factor do? With the ability to show notifications is clearly desk stakes for smartwatches. Given Samsung’s health push with S Well being in recent times, the S2 clearly additionally doubles as a extra-than-respectable exercise tracker — coronary heart fee readings appeared correct in comparison with different wearables and my very own finger-to-neck counts, as did the variety of steps it thought I took every day. Shopping by means of music is straightforward and you may management no matter participant you are utilizing, be it Spotify, Audible or Samsung’s personal Milk music service.

With a submit-setup set up courtesy of Right here, the Gear S2 may also be used as a tiny map that pinpoints your location, which is neat as a parlor trick and never a lot else. Positive, it is fairly fast to seek out you and spinning the bezel to zoom out and in is neat, nevertheless it’s sluggish at updating the map view whenever you transfer it round and does not show something however probably the most main close by road names. Save your self a headache and simply whip your telephone out.

You’ll be able to even reply to messages proper from the watch by firing off a canned response, pecking out a reply on the tiny, telephone-fashion keyboard (which is not as terrible because it sounds) or letting the watch transcribe what you are saying. That final bit manages to be the trickiest of the three — S Voice is not all the time nice at determining what I am making an attempt to say, so utilizing my voice to answer messages typically turned out to be workouts in excessive endurance. Different occasions, although, S Voice labored like a appeal. It as soon as rendered my aspect of a convoluted, spoken dialog and not using a single typo, apart from missed punctuation that I did not really feel like talking aloud.

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

To my shock, the Gear S had a number of huge-identify preloaded apps too, like Nike Operating, Bloomberg and CNN. A fast tour of the Gear S2’s nascent app retailer reveals a number of different notable additions like Yelp, ESPN, Flipboard and Line, most of which well reap the benefits of the spinning bezel. To be clear, although, the polished fruits of those partnerships stick out in comparison with the remainder of the S2’s obtainable apps.

As we have established, the Gear S2 runs Samsung’s Tizen cellular OS, which is each good and dangerous information. On the one hand, Samsung achieved a degree of integration, magnificence and management that would not have been potential if it constructed a look ahead to a competing platform like Android Put on. However, there aren’t many good apps obtainable. Notice that I am not saying there aren’t an entire lot of apps interval; Samsung has stated that there are about 1,000 for the Gear S2, which is not too shabby contemplating the watch seems to be and runs in contrast to all the firm’s earlier wearables. Usually I’d take a tool just like the Gear S2 to process for that restricted developer help, however I am unusually glad with the performance the watch brings to the desk. This model of the watch does not attempt to be a alternative on your smartphone — that is for the pricier 3G model coming quickly. Getting information updates and the occasional down-low on a close-by restaurant along with the notifications and well being monitoring I discover most precious is lots for me (and positively others too). Nonetheless, these of you in search of a better quantity of high quality apps had greatest look elsewhere.

Past the Galaxy

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

In contrast to each different non-Galaxy Gear watch Samsung has made, the S2 was constructed to play good with Android telephones from different producers. The corporate prompt that I check the S2 with a Samsung telephone (for apparent causes) so I spent about 4 days with it paired to a Galaxy Observe 5. However the place’s the enjoyable in simply doing that? A few week in, I ditched the Notice and hooked the S2 as much as a Moto X Pure Version as an alternative and did not discover any modifications within the expertise. The one catch is that your telephone has to run Android four.four or larger and have at the very least 1.5GB of RAM — most respectable telephones launched within the final two years ought to be capable of meet these necessities.

Samsung was clear that some options would not work as meant on third-social gathering telephones as a result of the parents who made them hadn’t constructed their software program to interface with the S2, however this actually hasn’t been a problem throughout day-to-day use. Each time I assumed I caught some type of platform hiccup — say, not with the ability to name my good friend Anthony utilizing voice instructions — I used to be truly simply lacking one thing. On this case, you’ll be able to solely ship transcribed messages and provoke telephone calls to one of many eleven individuals you’ve got designated as “buddies.” I am going to maintain throwing random units on the Gear S2 to see if it falters, however it seems to be prefer it runs simply as properly with third-get together telephones as with Samsung-made units.

Efficiency and battery life

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

Placing the app-availability situation apart, the Gear S2 as an entire works actually properly. Spinning via apps feels as quick because it does intuitive, and I by no means observed a slowdown whereas clicking via widgets and lengthy emails. That, in fact, doesn’t suggest the S2 is an ideal package deal. I used to be able to name the Gear S2 one of many least hiccup-y devices I’ve performed with in a very long time… till someday it all of a sudden stopped responding to faucets or bezel spins. The state of affairs fastened itself after leaving the Watch alone for a minute or two till the display went darkish because it usually did, however the occasion was barely surprising because the watch has in any other case been rock-strong.

The vibration motor can also be surprisingly weak, particularly for those who like utilizing smartwatches for pulsating wake-up calls. It does not have a speaker so it could’t emit any sound, and the vibrations — whereas completely enough for notifications whereas I am awake — are so slight they by no means as soon as woke me on time. Naturally, issues may go out in another way for you and your sleep patterns, however heavy dozers will need to maintain their 50 telephone alarms on simply in case.

On the very least, you possibly can sleep with the Gear S2 in your wrist and never fear about it operating out of juice earlier than morning. I wish to assume I’ve put it by means of a reasonably strenuous week of testing: Along with taking it out on runs, I’ve additionally been pulling in notifications from Slack, Outlook, Instagram and Google Hangouts, in addition to performing the occasional S Voice command. Even with all that happening, the Gear S2 routinely hung in for round three full working days — we’re speaking about forty hours on my wrists between costs, whereas all these notifications have been flowing in and with the display brightness set to a cushty 70 %. Keep in mind, that is with the S2’s default settings in place so the face shuts off utterly when it isn’t getting used. With the display set to remain on on a regular basis, the S2 eked out over two working days, or a few day and a half of use earlier than requiring a visit to the wi-fi charging dock. And don’t be concerned, you will get loads of discover earlier than the battery state of affairs grows dire — reminders to activate Energy Saver mode begin popping up at 10 %, and once more at 5 %.

The competitors

Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

Because the Gear S2 is an Android-solely system, it is no shock that Android Put on units just like the new Moto 360 are its largest rivals. Though the bottom mannequin 42mm Moto 360 prices the identical because the Gear S2, Android Put on’s broad developer help and the watch’s classically good-looking design make it a critical various to Samsung’s newest, even when its interface is nowhere close to as elegant. In fact, if the mere concept of notifications in your wrist is what will get you going, there isn’t any scarcity of cheaper-however-nonetheless-trendy choices. The unique ASUS ZenWatch was a good Android Put on watch that simply obtained a low cost, useful sequel ($one hundred fifty) and the Pebble Time Metal ($250) may do you properly if the Gear S2’s battery life spoke to you — the colour e-paper watch can run for as much as 10 days earlier than giving up the ghost.


Gear S2 review: Samsung's best smartwatch is still a work in progress

I by no means hated Samsung’s earlier wearables; in reality, I even obtained caught up within the publish-announcement rush a few times. That feeling is fleeting, although, and often evaporates a number of days after cracking open the field. The Gear S2 is totally different. I have been utilizing it for almost two weeks and it is the primary Samsung watch that hasn’t made me rely down the times till I used to be executed writing the evaluate. A variety of that’s due to the sensible, intuitive interface and the enjoyment of utilizing one thing that is sensible. Nonetheless, on the danger of sounding clichéd, the Gear S2 is not for everybody. The at present weak number of Tizen apps means you could be onerous-pressed to seek out issues value downloading, and that is going to be a non-starter for some individuals. The hit-or-miss nature of voice instructions stings too, particularly when different platforms are simply so good at it. And do not even get me began on the entire vibration factor once more. In the long run, the Gear S2 is an above-common smartwatch that sometimes shimmers with brilliance — this is hoping the sequel will get the developer like to make it a critical heavyweight.