Floor Professional three evaluation: Has Microsoft lastly made a pill to exchange your laptop computer?

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

It did not final lengthy, however there was a second earlier this week once I was positive Microsoft would unveil its personal laptop computer. At a press occasion, Floor chief Panos Panay took the stage to remind the reporters in attendance how they as soon as stated tablets would make laptops out of date. A fast scan across the room revealed rows of journalists, all typing on Ultrabooks — together with the MacBook Air, no much less. For a second, it appeared like Panay was conceding defeat.

Certainly, Microsoft has had a number of possibilities to show it may bridge the divide between slates and laptops: Each the primary- and second-gen Floor tablets have been meant as do-it-all units. And each occasions, the corporate fell in need of its mission. The Floor Professional particularly was highly effective sufficient to rival Ultrabooks, however suffered from a number of usability flaws: It was awkward to make use of within the lap, and in addition unwieldy as a pill. For most individuals, a touchscreen laptop computer was nonetheless the higher selection.

Even so, that wasn’t Panay conceding defeat up there on stage — that was him being persistent. When he lastly did get to the purpose, he unveiled not a laptop computer, however a pill, the Floor Professional three. Most notably, this third-gen system steps as much as a bigger, 12-inch display, bringing it consistent with modern Ultrabooks. The keyboard has been born once more too, this time with a bigger, extra responsive touchpad and the power to prop it up at a extra snug angle. As a pill, in the meantime, the Floor Professional three is thinner and lighter than the Floor Professional 2, regardless of having a much bigger show. Simply as necessary, the gadget will begin at $799 when it goes on sale subsequent month — that is 100 dollars lower than final yr’s mannequin. All advised, the Floor Professional three is Microsoft’s largest, quickest, thinnest, lightest, greatest pill but. Panay even went as far as to say, “Immediately we take the battle away.” Did they, although?

Gallery | 35 Pictures
Microsoft Floor Professional three evaluate

seventy nine

Floor Professional three


  • Remarkably skinny and lightweight for a machine with laptop computer guts
  • Simpler to make use of as a standalone pill
  • Quick efficiency
  • Beautiful, excessive-res show
  • Keyboard may be propped up at a extra snug angle


  • Flimsy keyboard is inferior to what you’d get on a correct laptop computer; worse, it does not even come within the field
  • Not that snug to make use of within the lap 
  • Middling battery life


The Floor Professional three is Microsoft’s largest and greatest pill but, nevertheless it wants a greater keyboard to really exchange your laptop computer.


Bodily talking, the Floor Professional three has extra in widespread with the Floor 2, which runs Home windows RT, than with earlier Floor Execs. This yr, Microsoft ditched the previous carbon-black colour in favor of a extra playful silver, although the chassis itself continues to be manufactured from sturdy magnesium alloy, with chamfered edges making it straightforward to wrap your fingers round. It isn’t simply the colour, although, that makes me consider the Floor 2: The Floor Professional three measures simply zero.36 inch thick, making it solely a tad fatter than the Home windows RT mannequin; that man is available in at zero.35 inch broad. That is beautiful whenever you keep in mind the Floor 2 is a standard pill, similar to the iPad, whereas the Floor Professional is principally an Ultrabook and not using a constructed-in keyboard. Actually, Microsoft says that is the thinnest machine with an Intel Core i7 processor. It might even be the lightest too, at 1.seventy six kilos. And even when it isn’t, it is nonetheless a significant enchancment — each the primary- and second-era Floor Execs weighed two kilos.

The Floor Professional’s thinness appears much more spectacular if you examine it to its friends: full-fledged Ultrabooks. Most thirteen-inch Ultras are available at round three kilos and half an inch thick (in the event that they’re fortunate). Even the eleven-inch MacBook Air, which advantages from a smaller footprint, ideas the scales at 2.38 kilos. Subsequent to these techniques, the Floor Professional three is impossibly compact. In truth, I used to be loath to return to my thirteen-inch MacBook Air after my evaluate was over; the brand new Floor is simply a lot lighter. Really, why cannot all Ultrabooks be this straightforward to hold?

As a pill, in fact, the Floor Professional nonetheless does not really feel notably mild; you do not simply overlook what it looks like to make use of a lighter gadget just like the iPad Air. That stated, it is undoubtedly lighter than a 12-inch pill has any proper to be. Additionally, there’s this: Regardless of that greater display — or perhaps as a result of of it — the Floor Professional three handles higher than its predecessors. For one factor, blowing up the display measurement truly allowed Microsoft to slim down the proportions. Give it some thought: With extra inner area to work with, the engineers have been capable of rearrange the elements, laying some gadgets aspect by aspect as an alternative of stacking them on prime of one another. The result’s a considerably thinner system which may not have been attainable had Microsoft caught with a ten.6-inch display measurement.

Moreover, the brand new Floor Professional has a special facet ratio: three:2, as an alternative of the standard sixteen:9. Throughout his keynote, Panay stated the corporate was actively making an attempt to imitate the size of a authorized pad, the type of object people are already used to holding, and dealing with. It was a sensible transfer, I feel: With this new form, the pill feels much less prime-heavy in portrait mode, and it is simpler to succeed in issues together with your thumbs in panorama. Goes to point out that weight discount is not the whole lot (although it undoubtedly helps).

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

As it’s, the Floor 2 and Floor Professional 2 have twin-stage kickstands that may be organized in one among two positions. The Floor Professional three goes a step additional — actually — with an choice to tug out the kickstand at a close to-flat one hundred fifty-diploma angle. That is helpful for those who’re enjoying a board recreation or utilizing a drawing app, and an upright angle will not do. All in all, too, the kickstand feels properly-constructed, if a bit inflexible. Granted, I would not need the hinge to maneuver so simply that it verges on snapping off. However the kickstand right here is so tightly wound that I truly really feel a bit naughty each time I push it again into that one hundred fifty-diploma place; there’s a lot friction that once I push the stand again, I really feel like I am doing one thing I am not purported to. It is also nonetheless a bit awkward to tug the kickstand out, since there’s solely a notch on one aspect of the pill. Once more, although, it feels sturdy, and nonetheless makes that mushy “click on” sound each time you snap it shut.

Regardless of the larger measurement, the port choice is identical as ever. Meaning: an influence button on the highest panorama edge; a Mini DisplayPort and USB three.zero connection on the correct; and a quantity rocker and headphone jack on the left. The underside, in fact, is house to the magnetic guides that permit it to click on into the non-compulsory Sort Cowl keyboard (extra on that in a second). There’s additionally a microSD slot tucked beneath the kickstand, supporting playing cards as giant as 128GB. Microsoft additionally upgraded the cameras in order that each go as much as 5-megapixel decision. In the meantime, there is a proprietary charging port on the fitting aspect, slightly below the USB socket. Although the charger stays put, it is nonetheless awkward to insert — a minor annoyance you will certainly get used to, do you have to select to purchase this. As for the entrance-dealing with audio system, stated to be forty five % louder than final yr’s mannequin, they move my “Dolly Parton rundown check” with flying colours. (They make other forms of music sound good, too.)

Show and pen enter

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

The Floor tablets have all the time had pretty shows, and the third-gen Professional is not any exception. What we now have here’s a 12-inch, 2,one hundred sixty x 1,440 IPS panel, with textual content so sharp you’d need to put your nostril up towards the display to see any pixels. Colours are punchy, however balanced, and the viewing angles are good too, although even a low-glare display like this is not resistant to reflections from overhead mild. Generally, I had little hassle studying the display, however utilizing the Floor in my lap was typically difficult; probably the most secure kickstand place does not essentially imply one of the best viewing angles.

Beneath the hood, Microsoft used some totally different pen know-how this time round: an lively digitizer made by N-trig, versus Wacom. Whereas it’d sound like I am harping on specs there, hear me out: You will be making some commerce-offs. On the one hand, Wacom’s digitizer provided extra nuanced strain sensitivity: 1,024 levels, versus 256 from N-trig. However, N-trig’s setup permits for a thinner glass show and thus, a slimmer general design. Moreover, N-trig’s pen was designed to really feel extra like a correct, ink-based mostly pen, and is subsequently extra pure to carry. Likewise, the display has simply sufficient friction that drawing on it feels extra like dragging a pen throughout a pad of paper — or as shut as you will get, anyway. Personally, I might select a thinner, lighter system over extra exact strain sensitivity, however hey, do not let me set your priorities for you.

As you are utilizing the pen, you will discover it does some previous tips, together with some new ones too. It helps hovering, for example, and you need to use the highest button as an eraser in choose apps. On a extra shocking notice, you possibly can press that prime button to wake the pill from sleep, at which level OneNote will open above the lock display. Sort of like how one can already use the digital camera app from the Home windows eight.1 lock display. Additionally, OneNote now sends your scribbles to the cloud as you are writing them — not in contrast to the way you’d anticipate Google Drive to right away save your work.

As with earlier Floor units, there isn’t any place on the pill to stow the pen. Moderately, you are supposed to slide it inside a loop that attaches to both the Floor or the elective Sort Cowl keyboard. Sadly, the factor fell off after just some days of use, which suggests you are in all probability by yourself on the subject of ensuring you do not lose your writing implement.

Typing expertise

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

Simply so you understand, I am typing this sentence from a Floor Professional three. The factor is sitting in my lap, even. And you already know what? I am doing alright. This is not my favourite laptop computer keyboard — not by an extended shot — however I am doing OK. And I feel you’ll too. However earlier than I get forward of myself, let me clarify what you are getting right here. The very first thing you must know, maybe, is that there is only one keyboard choice: a backlit Sort Cowl keyboard constructed particularly for the Floor Professional three’s greater body. For now, at the very least, the flat Contact Cowl keyboard isn’t an choice. Frankly, I all the time most popular the bodily buttons anyway, simply because the training curve is a lot smaller. The one factor you will miss, perhaps, is the Contact Cowl’s lighter-weight design. However given the selection, I am going to take a extra pure typing expertise over a lighter keyboard any day. And hey, the pill’s already fairly mild; you possibly can cope with a number of additional ounces.

What I like greatest about this new keyboard is that I haven’t got to sort on a totally flat floor if I do not need to. In contrast to earlier Sort Covers, this one has a magnetic strip on the highest, permitting you to fold up the higher piece of the keyboard in order that it attaches firmly to the pill’s decrease bezel. The top result’s kind of a wedge profile, just like what you’d discover on a correct laptop computer. And it goes a great distance in making the factor extra snug to make use of. Thoughts you, no one’s forcing you to select the propped-up choice; you possibly can go flat if you wish to. I simply do not perceive why anybody would.

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

The issue is that the keyboard is flimsy, and it is nowhere as sturdy or snug as “actual” keyboards. As I sort this, I can see the keyboard cowl giving a bit underneath the load of my fingers; it is sufficient to make me not need to use it in my lap (although I do it anyway, out of necessity). With each keystroke, I make a loud “clack,” letting anybody round me know I am getting stuff accomplished. The keys are additionally bunched shut collectively — the other of your normal chiclet format. Meaning it is slightly too straightforward to hit the fallacious key. Fortunately for me, I’ve a replica editor, so you possibly can’t inform what number of typos I truly made whereas scripting this evaluation. Suffice to say, it was sufficient that I ultimately began to sort extra gingerly, within the hopes I would not make fairly as many errors.

The Floor Professional three’s Sort Cowl additionally brings an improved touchpad. And that is good timing, as a result of the newest Home windows eight.1 replace made the OS far more mouse-and-keyboard pleasant. In short, the trackpad right here is greater, with a constructed-in contact button you’ll be able to press down on. It is also stated to be extra responsive, however I will be the decide of that, not Microsoft. Even when the trackpad is extra exact than it was, it is nonetheless many steps behind the kind of glass touchpad you’d discover on the MacBook Air or many Home windows Ultrabooks. It typically takes a number of tries to get two-finger scrolling to work. Ditto for clicking and dragging home windows and different objects across the display. Different occasions, I by chance navigated backward out of an internet web page once I was actually making an attempt to do another kind of gesture. When you’re critical about having a mouse, particularly in desktop mode, you may be higher off utilizing a Bluetooth one, particularly in case you intend the Floor Professional to be your every day driver.

Efficiency and battery life PCMark7 3DMark06 3DMark11 ATTO (prime disk speeds) Microsoft Floor Professional three (1.9GHz Core i5-4300U, Intel HD 4400) 5,024 5,053

E1,313 / P984

555 MB/s (reads); 252 MB/s (writes) Microsoft Floor Professional 2 (1.6GHz Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,922 6,236

E1,906 / P997 / X303

534 MB/s (reads); 167 MB/s (writes) Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (2014, 1.6GHz Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,773 5,881

E1,727 / P930 / X284

555 MB/s (reads); 137 MB/s (writes) HP Spectre thirteen Ultrabook (1.6GHz Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,786 6,005

E1,837 / P962 / X293

527 MB/s (reads); 327 MB/s (writes) Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga 2 Professional (1.6GHz Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,676 5,688

E1,713 / P914 / X281

546 MB/s (reads); 139 MB/s (writes) Samsung ATIV Ebook 9 Lite (1.4GHz “quad-core” processor, AMD Radeon HD 8250) 2,060 2,814

E749 / P530

550 MB/s (reads); 139 MB/s (writes) Samsung ATIV E-book 9 Plus (1.6GHz Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,973 5,611

E1,675 / P867 / X277

547 MB/s (reads); 508 MB/s (writes) Acer Aspire S7-392 (1.6GHz Intel Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) 5,108 5,158

E1,724 / P952 / X298

975 MB/s (reads); 1.1 GB/s (writes) Sony VAIO Professional thirteen (1.6GHz Intel Core i5-4200U, Intel HD 4400) four,502 four,413

E1,177 / P636 / X203

1.04 GB/s (reads); 479 MB/s (writes) Sony VAIO Professional eleven (1.8GHz Core i7-4500U, Intel HD 4400) four,634 N/A

E1,067 / P600 / X183

558 MB/s (reads); 255 MB/s (writes)

Make no mistake: In relation to efficiency, the Floor Professional has all the time been capable of go face to face with conventional laptops. Nonetheless, it is good to know that as different Ultrabooks have skilled modest efficiency positive factors, Microsoft has stored tempo. Armed with a Haswell processor (a 1.9GHz Core i5-4300U chip), 8GB of RAM, a Samsung-made strong-state drive and the standard Intel HD 4400 graphics, the Floor Professional three holds its personal in artificial benchmark checks, with scores that fall according to the competitors. It additionally boots shortly, taking simply 10 seconds to get to the lock display after which another to load the Begin Display. My WiFi connection was persistently quick too, because of the 802.11ac radio inside (there’s additionally Bluetooth four.zero, for those who want it).

Accordingly, the Floor Professional three can do all the things an Ultrabook can do. Certainly one of my favourite issues about engaged on a Home windows machine is the Snap function, so I routinely have two packages laid out aspect by aspect — often Chrome and HipChat. Particularly, I typically have a dozen tabs open directly, together with Gmail, my calendar, Engadget, Fb, Twitter and the publishing software program we use to write down tales, to not point out the odd Wikipedia web page and music-streaming service. Along with the standard multitasking, you possibly can additionally edit pictures in case you needed, or perhaps even reduce collectively some video.

All through, the metallic surfaces stayed comparatively cool, and I did not hear a lot noise popping out of the skinny vent that surrounds the perimeter of the gadget. As with each different Ultrabook, although, the brand new Floor wheezes a bit throughout gameplay. Load up a recreation and the factor will get fairly heat — virtually scorching — to the contact. Scorching and noisy, too. At one level, the followers began exhaling so loudly that I heard them even in a loft area with numerous coworkers milling round close by. If I can hear it over all that ambient noise, properly, that is not good. Fortuitously, it takes so much to make the system pipe up like that. And for those who do, it might be that you simply’re doing one thing Ultrabooks weren’t truly designed for.

Battery life

Microsoft Floor Professional three 7:08 MacBook Air (thirteen-inch, 2013) 12:fifty one MacBook Professional with Retina show (thirteen-inch, 2013) eleven:18 Sony VAIO Duo thirteen 9:forty Samsung ATIV E-book 9 Plus eight:forty four HP Spectre thirteen eight:30 Sony VAIO Professional thirteen eight:24 Lenovo IdeaPad U430 Contact 7:fifty three Acer Aspire S7-392 7:33 Acer Iconia W700 7:thirteen Sony VAIO Professional eleven 6:forty one Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga 2 Professional 6:32 Microsoft Floor Professional 2 6:27 Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (2014) 6:18 Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga thirteen 5:32 Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (2013) 5:07 Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Contact (2013) 5:00 Samsung ATIV E-book 9 Lite four:33

Microsoft describes the Floor Professional three’s battery life in two methods: You possibly can rise up to 9 hours of net browsing (WiFi on, auto-brightness turned off), or you’ll be able to merely anticipate a 15 to twenty % improve over earlier fashions. Translation: Your mileage will range, however battery life might be improved both method. And improved it’s. In our video-looping check (additionally with WiFi on and auto-brightness disabled), the pill managed seven hours and eight minutes. Examine that with the Floor Professional 2, which could not crack six and a half hours.

Now, let’s put that seven-hour battery life in context. Briefly, it isn’t nice, however it’s not dangerous, both. Different ultraportables which are both small in measurement or tremendous light-weight have tended to final an identical period of time (see: the Acer Aspire S7-392 or the Sony VAIO Professional eleven). Even some bigger Ultrabooks, like Lenovo’s Yoga 2 Professional and ThinkPad X1 Carbon, ship much less runtime regardless of having room for greater batteries. The factor is, in fact, there are numerous Ultrabooks that final a lot, for much longer on a cost. The HP Spectre thirteen, Sony VAIO Professional thirteen, Sony Duo thirteen and Samsung ATIV E-book 9 Plus all final round eight and half hours, if not nearer to 10. (The MacBook Air can go even longer, although I’ve by no means examined the eleven-inch mannequin.)

Although the Floor Professional three is missing in battery life in comparison with bigger Ultrabooks, it no less than costs shortly. After pushing the battery to its limits, I received again as much as seventy two % in round ninety minutes. So, even should you solely have a short while to recharge, you need to nonetheless get well sufficient juice to final you thru a pair hours of labor. And by the point that runs out, you in all probability could have discovered one other outlet.

Replace: After continued testing, we began to get even greater benchmark scores for the Floor Professional three. We have up to date the above benchmark desk to incorporate these.

Configuration choices and the competitors

Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

The Floor Professional three may be both sorta costly or actually costly, relying on the specs you select. On the low finish, there is a Core i3 mannequin with 64GB of storage, priced at $799. The subsequent step up is a Core i5 configuration with 128GB of storage; that’ll promote for $999. To get that very same Core i5 unit with 256GB of storage as an alternative, you will pay $1,299. Rounding out the record are two Core i7 fashions: one with 256GB of storage and the opposite with 512GB. These will value you $1,549 and $1,949, respectively. As of this writing, the 2 Core i5 fashions have been slated to ship on June twentieth. The Core i3 and Core i7 configurations, in the meantime, aren’t delivery till August thirty first, based on Microsoft’s on-line retailer. Both means, you possibly can pre-order any of them now, when you like.

Sadly, whichever you decide, the $one hundred thirty Sort Cowl keyboard is bought individually, which suggests the Floor Professional three instantly suffers in comparisons with correct Ultrabooks, just like the Yoga 2 Professional ($1,199), Dell XPS 12 ($1,000), Acer Aspire S7-392 ($1,300) and the Samsung ATIV Ebook 9 Plus ($1,four hundred). As an example, for those who needed the Floor Professional three with a Core i5 processor, 8GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD, you’d pay $1,299 for the laptop computer and $one hundred thirty for the keyboard, for a complete of about $1,430. The Yoga 2 Professional with comparable specs is presently going for $1,399, with a web-based worth of $1,199.

And there is the rub: With a subpar keyboard, how can the Floor Professional really be a laptop computer killer? And if the thought is for the Floor Professional to go face to face with Ultrabooks, the keyboard also needs to be included free of charge. However it’s particularly dangerous if that $one hundred thirty keyboard is not even that snug to sort on. So what do you find yourself with, then? A tool that is barely costlier than comparable laptops, with an inferior typing expertise. If you put it that means, it is robust to offer this a glowing suggestion.


Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

With every era of Floor units, Microsoft will get nearer to constructing a tool that may substitute each your pill and laptop computer. Sadly, although, the corporate’s progress has been gradual, and even after three makes an attempt, it nonetheless hasn’t addressed some critical usability flaws. This time round, the most important drawback is the keyboard. It is robust to say who can purchase the Floor Professional three as a laptop computer various when the very factor that makes it a pocket book alternative — its elective keyboard — gives a subpar typing expertise and a irritating trackpad. Including insult to damage, it isn’t even included within the field; it is an optionally available $one hundred thirty accent that helps drive up the fee in comparison with comparable PCs.

The excellent news is that regardless of its bigger display measurement, the Floor Professional is simpler than ever to make use of as a pill, because of a thinner, lighter design and extra smart facet ratio. If Microsoft might simply work out the keyboard factor (and begin throwing it in at no cost), I might be extra inclined to advocate this as a laptop computer alternative. For now, until you need a pill and laptop computer in equal measure, and sincerely take pleasure in utilizing Home windows Retailer apps, a touchscreen Ultrabook continues to be your greatest guess.

Edgar Alvarez and Zach Honig contributed to this evaluation.

 Disguise Feedback zeroFeedback

<a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/microsoft/floor/home windows-eight-professional/”> Microsoft Floor Home windows eight Professional </a>

  • Key specs
  • <a href=”http://www.engadget.com/merchandise/microsoft/floor/home windows-eight-professional/” title=”Microsoft Floor Home windows eight Professional evaluations” goal=”_blank”> Evaluations forty one </a>
  • Costs
  • Discussions
  • Sort Pill
  • Type issue Slate
  • Display measurement 10.6 inches
  • Processor velocity 1.7 GHz
  • System RAM four GB
  • Dimensions 6.eighty one x 10.eighty one x zero.fifty three in
  • Weight 2 lb
  • Launched 2013-02-09

see all specs →

eight.7common consumer score
  • Velocity and options 9.three
  • Design and type issue 9.1
  • Battery life 6.7
  • Show 9.four
  • Sturdiness eight.eight
  • Expandability eight.6
  • Noise 9.1
  • Portability (measurement / weight) eight.7

Get higher critiques from individuals who even have this product!

write a evaluatesee all critiques →

Displaying costs for mannequin:


  • Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop? + tax & delivery Purchase now
  • NewEgg Market + tax & delivery Purchase now
  • Featured Tales
    Examine Your Devices

    Surface Pro 3 review: Has Microsoft finally made a tablet to replace your laptop?

    Immediately examine merchandise aspect by aspect and see which one is greatest for you!

    Attempt it now →