Apple’s Tim Prepare dinner “deeply offended” by recent allegations of manufacturing unit employee mistreatment

Apple's Tim Cook "deeply offended" by fresh allegations of factory worker mistreatment

Apple CEO Tim Prepare dinner has stated he is “deeply offended” by recent allegations of poor working circumstances in its Chinese language factories. Contractors employed by Apple to assemble its newest merchandise have been criticized earlier than over poor working circumstances, and whereas the agency has tried to be extra proactive in recent times, a new BBC investigation suggests the issues nonetheless persist. Undercover reporters employed at Pegatron factories found an exhausted workforce often falling asleep on the manufacturing line. Twelve hour shifts are widespread, which suggests staff typically clock over 60 hours on the manufacturing unit flooring every week — properly above China’s forty four-hour working week, however probably authorized given the nation additionally permits 36 hours of additional time per 30 days.

The BBC additionally highlighted different mispractices. One journalist was pressured handy over his id card, breaking native legal guidelines that require everybody to hold an ID always. Throughout a well being and security check, which is a part of the induction course of, examiners could be heard giving potential staff the solutions. Moreover, when requested about working preferences, it is implied that candidates are required to choose into working nights and shifts that require standing up for lengthy durations of time. Overcrowding — a scorching challenge when Apple was criticized over Foxconn manufacturing unit circumstances a few years in the past, is seemingly nonetheless an issue. In a single Pegatron dormitory twelve individuals have been sharing a single room, when Apple’s tips state the utmost ought to be eight.

As you’d anticipate, Apple has moved shortly to discredit the BBC documentary. An inner Apple memo despatched to UK staff, acquired by The Telegraph, stated: “Panorama’s report implied that Apple is not enhancing working circumstances. Let me inform you, nothing could possibly be farther from the reality.” The letter was written by Apple SVP of operations Jeff Williams, who notes “Tim [Cook] and I have been deeply offended” by the BBC’s allegations. Williams goes on to argue that “no different firm [is] doing as a lot as Apple does to make sure truthful and protected working circumstances, to find and examine issues, to repair and comply with by way of when points come up, and to offer transparency into the operations of our suppliers.”

The corporate reminded staff that its personal engineers and managers are “always” within the factories to supervise manufacturing, and can report again on any security considerations and situations of employee mistreatment. It additionally took concern with the work hours reported by the BBC, claiming that suppliers at the moment are hitting ninety three-% compliance for the weekly restrict. However because the BBC’s documentary has proven, suppliers look like bending the principles as a way to full the required paperwork and due diligence.

Apple’s full letter to staff:

UK Group,

As you recognize, Apple is devoted to the development of human rights and equality all over the world. We’re trustworthy concerning the challenges we face and we work arduous to ensure that individuals who make our merchandise are handled with the dignity and respect they deserve.

Final night time, the BBC’s Panorama program referred to as these values into query. Like lots of you, Tim and I have been deeply offended by the suggestion that Apple would break a promise to the employees in our provide chain or mislead our clients in any approach.

I might like to offer you information and perspective, all of which we shared with the BBC prematurely, however have been clearly lacking from their program.

Panorama confirmed a few of the surprising circumstances round tin mining in Indonesia. Apple has publicly said that tin from Indonesia results in our merchandise, and a few of that tin probably comes from unlawful mines. Listed here are the details:

Tens of hundreds of artisanal miners are promoting tin via many middlemen to the smelters who provide to element suppliers who promote to the world. The federal government just isn’t addressing the difficulty, and there’s widespread corruption within the undeveloped provide chain. Our staff visited the identical elements of Indonesia visited by the BBC, and naturally we’re appalled by what is going on on there.

Apple has two decisions: We might be sure that all of our suppliers purchase tin from smelters outdoors of Indonesia, which might in all probability be the simplest factor for us to do and would definitely defend us from criticism. However it will be the lazy and cowardly path, as a result of it will do nothing to enhance the state of affairs for Indonesian staff or the setting since Apple consumes a tiny fraction of the tin mined there. We selected the second path, which is to remain engaged and attempt to drive a collective answer. We spearheaded the creation of an Indonesian Tin Working Group with different know-how corporations. Apple is pushing to seek out and implement a system that holds smelters accountable so we will affect artisanal mining in Indonesia. It might be an strategy corresponding to “bagging and tagging” legally mined materials, which has been profitable over time within the Democratic Republic of the Congo. We want to drive comparable leads to Indonesia, which is the proper factor to do.

Panorama additionally made claims about our dedication to working circumstances in our factories. We all know of no different firm doing as a lot as Apple does to make sure truthful and protected working circumstances, to find and examine issues, to repair and comply with via when points come up, and to offer transparency into the operations of our suppliers.

I would like you to know that greater than 1400 of your Apple coworkers are stationed in China to handle our manufacturing operations. They’re within the factories always – gifted engineers and managers who’re additionally compassionate individuals, educated to talk up once they see security dangers or mistreatment. We even have a group of specialists devoted solely to driving compliance with our Provider Code of Conduct throughout our huge provide chain.

In 2014 alone, our Provider Duty workforce accomplished 630 complete, in-individual audits deep into our provide chain. These audits embrace face-to-face interviews with staff, away from their managers, of their native language. Typically critics level to the invention of issues as proof that the method is not working. The truth is that we discover violations in each audit we have now ever carried out, regardless of how refined the corporate we’re auditing. We discover issues, we drive enchancment, after which we increase the bar.

Panorama’s report implied that Apple is not enhancing working circumstances. Let me inform you, nothing might be farther from the reality. Listed here are just some examples:

A number of years in the past, the overwhelming majority of staff in our provide chain labored in extra of 60 hours, and 70+ hour workweeks have been typical. After years of sluggish progress and business excuses, Apple determined to assault the issue by monitoring the weekly hours of over a million staff, driving corrective actions with our suppliers and publishing the outcomes on our web site month-to-month – one thing no different firm had ever accomplished. It takes substantial effort, and we’ve to weed out false reporting, however it’s working. This yr, our suppliers have achieved a mean of ninety three% compliance with our 60-hour restrict. We will nonetheless do higher.

And we’ll.

Our auditors have been the primary to determine and crack down on a hoop of unscrupulous labor brokers who have been holding staff’ passports and forcing them to pay exorbitant charges. Thus far, we’ve helped staff recoup $20 million in extreme funds like these. We have gone far past auditing and corrective actions by creating instructional packages for staff in the identical amenities the place they make our merchandise. Greater than 750,000 individuals have taken benefit of those school-degree programs and enrichment packages, and the suggestions we get from college students is inspiring

I can’t dive into each difficulty raised by Panorama on this observe, however you’ll be able to relaxation assured that we take all allegations critically, and we examine each declare. We all know there are a variety of points on the market, and our work isn’t achieved. We won’t relaxation till each individual in our provide chain is handled with the respect and dignity they deserve.

If you would like to study extra about our Provider Duty program, I encourage you and our clients to go to our web site at

Thanks in your time and your help.


 Cover Feedback zeroFeedback

<a href=””> Apple iPad Air 2 </a>

  • Key specs
  • <a href=”” title=”Apple iPad Air 2 evaluations” goal=”_blank”> Evaluations 5 </a>
  • Costs
  • Discussions
  • Type issue Pill
  • Working system iOS (eight)
  • Display measurement 9.7 inches
  • Storage sort Inner storage (sixteen GB, Flash)
  • Most battery life As much as 10 hours
  • Dimensions 9.four x 6.6 x zero.24 in
  • Weight zero.ninety six lb
  • Introduced 2014-10-sixteen

see all specs →

9.2common consumer score
  • Options 9.2
  • Show eight.eight
  • Battery life eight
  • Ease of use 10
  • Storage capability 9.2
  • Design and type issue 10
  • Portability (measurement / weight) 9.6
  • Sturdiness eight

Get higher critiques from individuals who even have this product!

write a evaluationsee all evaluations →

Displaying costs for mannequin:


  • Apple's Tim Cook "deeply offended" by fresh allegations of factory worker mistreatment + tax & delivery Purchase now
  • Featured Tales
    Examine Your Devices

    Apple's Tim Cook "deeply offended" by fresh allegations of factory worker mistreatment

    Immediately examine merchandise aspect by aspect and see which one is greatest for you!

    Attempt it now →